Zdravko Petanjek, Department of Anatomy and Clinical Anatomy and Croatian Institute for Brain Research, University of Zagreb School of Medicine, Šalata 11, 10 000 Zagreb, Croatia,
Croat Med J. 2021 Apr 30;62(2):173-186. doi: 10.3325/cmj.2021.62.173.
To compare the efficacy of different components of online and contact anatomy classes as perceived by medical students.
An anonymous course evaluation survey was conducted at the end of the academic year 2019/2020. The organization of classes due to the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic provided our students with a unique opportunity to compare online and contact classes. Students' responses were analyzed according to the type of obtained data (ratio, ordinal, and categorical).
The response rate was 95.58%. Approximately 90% of students found anatomical dissection and practical work in general to be the most important aspect of teaching, which could not be replaced by online learning. During online classes, students missed the most the interaction with other students, followed by the interaction with student teaching assistants and teaching staff. Very few students found contact lectures useful, with most students reporting that they could be replaced with recorded video lectures. In contrast, recorded video lectures were perceived as extremely helpful for studying. Regular weekly quizzes were essential during online classes as they gave students adequate feedback and guided their learning process. Students greatly benefitted from additional course materials and interactive lessons, which were made easily available via e-learning platform.
Anatomical dissection and interaction during contact classes remain the most important aspects of teaching anatomy. However, online teaching increases learning efficiency by allowing alternative learning strategies and by substituting certain components of contact classes, thus freeing up more time for practical work.
比较医学生对在线和接触式解剖课程不同组成部分的效果感知。
在 2019/2020 学年结束时进行了匿名课程评估调查。由于 SARS-CoV-2 大流行,课程组织为学生提供了一个独特的机会,比较在线和接触式课程。根据获得的数据类型(比例、顺序和分类)分析学生的反应。
回复率为 95.58%。大约 90%的学生认为解剖学解剖和实践工作通常是教学的最重要方面,这是在线学习无法替代的。在在线课程中,学生最想念的是与其他学生的互动,其次是与学生助教和教学人员的互动。很少有学生认为接触式讲座有用,大多数学生报告说可以用录制的视频讲座代替。相比之下,录制的视频讲座对学习非常有帮助。在线课程中定期的每周测验至关重要,因为它们为学生提供了足够的反馈,并指导他们的学习过程。学生从额外的课程材料和互动课程中受益匪浅,这些课程通过电子学习平台轻松获得。
接触式课程中的解剖学解剖和互动仍然是教学解剖学的最重要方面。然而,在线教学通过允许替代学习策略和替代接触式课程的某些组成部分,提高了学习效率,从而为实践工作腾出了更多时间。