Public Health Graduate Program, University of São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil.
Department of Epidemiology, Public Health School, University of São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil.
Epidemiol Health. 2021;43:e2021031. doi: 10.4178/epih.e2021031. Epub 2021 May 1.
The aim of this study was to determine whether geographic location, socioeconomic status, infant mortality, and mortality from diarrheal disease in health regions are associated with the provision of community water fluoridation (CWF) in Brazilian municipalities.
A multilevel ecological study was conducted based on data from the National Survey of Basic Sanitation and Human Development Atlas. A multilevel analysis was carried out considering Brazilian municipalities as the first level and health regions as the second level, comprising sanitation, demographic, socioeconomic, and health characteristics.
The observation units comprised 5,565 municipalities clustered in 438 health regions in Brazil. The lack of CWF provision was positively associated with the following municipal characteristics: a below-median proportion of inhabitants covered by the sewage network, medium to very low human development index, below-median per capita gross domestic product, and an above-median percentage of expenditures on sanitation. In relation to the health regions, the likelihood of a lack of CWF provision was greater in the municipalities belonging to the health regions located in the Northern and Northeastern areas of Brazil and in those where child mortality due to acute diarrheal disease and the proportion of people with low income were higher when adjusted by municipal indicators.
Information on the characteristics associated with CWF provision constitutes important input for refocusing public policy to reduce inequalities among Brazilian municipalities and health regions. These findings may help policy-makers to understand the challenges facing CWF expansion in low-, middle-, and high-income countries.
本研究旨在确定地理位置、社会经济地位、婴儿死亡率以及卫生区域内腹泻病死亡率与巴西市政当局提供社区水氟化(CWF)之间的关系。
本研究基于国家基本卫生调查和人类发展地图集的数据,采用多水平生态研究方法。多水平分析考虑了巴西市政当局作为第一级和卫生区域作为第二级,包括卫生、人口、社会经济和健康特征。
观察单位包括巴西 5565 个市政当局,这些市政当局聚类为 438 个卫生区域。缺乏 CWF 供应与以下市政特征呈正相关:污水管网覆盖居民比例低于中位数、人类发展指数中等至非常低、人均国内生产总值中位数以下、卫生支出比例中位数以上。就卫生区域而言,在属于巴西北部和东北部地区的市政当局以及那些因急性腹泻病导致儿童死亡率较高且低收入人群比例较高的市政当局,缺乏 CWF 供应的可能性更大,这是在调整了市政指标后的结果。
与 CWF 供应相关的特征信息是重新调整公共政策以减少巴西市政当局和卫生区域之间不平等的重要依据。这些发现可能有助于决策者了解在低收入、中等收入和高收入国家中扩大 CWF 所面临的挑战。