Social and Behavioral Sciences Department, Yale School of Public Health, New Haven, Connecticut, USA.
J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci. 2022 Apr 1;77(4):e70-e75. doi: 10.1093/geronb/gbab085.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, stigmatization of older persons increased in traditional and social media. It was unknown whether this negative messaging could be detrimental to the mental health of older individuals, and whether the relatively uncommon positive messaging about older individuals could benefit their mental health.
To address these gaps, we designed age-stereotype interventions based on actual news stories that appeared during the pandemic, and divided them into negative and positive versions of what we term personified (i.e., individual-based) and enumerative (i.e., number-based) age-stereotype messaging. The negative versions of the 2 types of messaging reflected the age stereotype of decline, whereas the positive versions of the 2 types of messaging reflected the age stereotype of resilience.
As expected, the exposure of older individuals to the negative-age-stereotype-messaging interventions led to significantly worse mental health (i.e., more anxiety and less peacefulness), compared to a neutral condition; in contrast, the positive-age-stereotype-messaging interventions led to significantly better mental health (i.e., less anxiety and more peacefulness), compared to a neutral condition. The findings were equally strong for the personified and enumerative conditions. Also as expected, the interventions, which were self-irrelevant to the younger participants, did not significantly impact their mental health.
This is the first-known study to experimentally demonstrate that institutional ageism, and statistics that reflect stereotypes about older individuals, can impact mental health. The results demonstrate the need for media messaging aimed at empowering older individuals during the pandemic and beyond.
在 COVID-19 大流行期间,传统媒体和社交媒体对老年人的污名化有所增加。尚不清楚这种负面信息是否会对老年人的心理健康造成损害,以及关于老年人的相对较少的积极信息是否会有益于他们的心理健康。
为了解决这些差距,我们根据大流行期间出现的真实新闻故事设计了基于年龄刻板印象的干预措施,并将其分为我们所谓的拟人化(即基于个人)和枚举(即基于数字)的负面和正面版本的年龄刻板印象信息。这 2 种信息类型的负面版本反映了衰退的年龄刻板印象,而这 2 种信息类型的正面版本反映了韧性的年龄刻板印象。
正如预期的那样,与中性条件相比,老年人接触到的负面年龄刻板印象信息干预措施导致心理健康明显恶化(即焦虑感增加,平静感减少);相比之下,积极的年龄刻板印象信息干预措施导致心理健康明显改善(即焦虑感减少,平静感增加),与中性条件相比。拟人化和枚举条件的结果同样强烈。同样如预期的那样,这些干预措施与年轻参与者自我无关,不会对他们的心理健康产生显著影响。
这是第一项已知的研究,它通过实验证明了制度年龄歧视和反映老年人刻板印象的统计数据会影响心理健康。结果表明,在大流行期间及以后,需要有针对性地向老年人传递媒体信息,赋予他们权力。