Centro de Investigaciones en Geografía Ambiental, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Campus Morelia, Mexico; Área de Ecología, Instituto del Conurbano, Universidad Nacional de General Sarmiento, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Sci Total Environ. 2021 Sep 10;786:147481. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.147481. Epub 2021 May 3.
The concepts of sustainability and sustainable development have acquired great relevance in scientific research about environmental issues, policies linked to environmental management, and industrial and agricultural production, among others. Although these two concepts are frequently used as synonyms, they are immersed in debates regarding their meaning and their possibilities for application to real systems. This review analyzes the main theoretical definitions of both concepts, together with their potentials and limitations, emphasizing the differences between their meanings. A bibliographic search was carried out in the Web of Science database and other sources from official organizations of international relevance and authors referenced by them. The works providing substantive definitions of sustainability and sustainable development from a complexity theory perspective were selected for discussion throughout the article. The main results showed a strong criticism of the concept of sustainable development due to its imprecise definition, the emergence of the concept of sustainability in the debate of the 1990s and its consolidation in certain fields of knowledge, and the emergence of new alternatives to sustainable development such as degrowth and buen vivir. The results also show the potential of the concept of sustainability as a still-developing framework for scientific research and environmental management.
可持续性和可持续发展这两个概念在环境问题的科学研究、与环境管理相关的政策以及工业和农业生产等领域都具有重要意义。尽管这两个概念经常被用作同义词,但它们在其含义及其在实际系统中的应用可能性方面存在争议。本综述分析了这两个概念的主要理论定义,以及它们的潜力和局限性,强调了它们含义之间的差异。在 Web of Science 数据库和其他具有国际重要性的官方组织及其引用的来源中进行了文献检索。本文选择了从复杂性理论角度对可持续性和可持续发展提供实质性定义的著作进行讨论。主要结果表明,由于可持续发展概念定义不精确,可持续性概念在 20 世纪 90 年代的辩论中出现,并在某些知识领域得到巩固,以及诸如去增长和美好生活等可持续发展的新替代方案的出现,对可持续发展概念提出了强烈批评。结果还表明,可持续性概念作为科学研究和环境管理的一个仍在发展的框架具有潜力。