Cornell University, Department of Government, White Hall, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States.
Cornell University, Department of Government, White Hall, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States.
Vaccine. 2021 Jun 2;39(24):3250-3258. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.04.044. Epub 2021 Apr 24.
Public health officials warn that the greatest barrier to widespread vaccination against Covid-19 will not be scientific or technical, but the considerable public hesitancy to take a novel vaccine. Understanding the factors that influence vaccine acceptance is critical to informing public health campaigns aiming to combat public fears and ensure broad uptake. Employing a conjoint experiment embedded on an online survey of almost 2,000 adult Americans, we show that the effects of seven vaccine attributes on subjects' willingness to vaccinate vary significantly across subgroups. Vaccine efficacy was significantly more influential on vaccine acceptance among whites than among Blacks, while bringing a vaccine to market under a Food and Drug Administration Emergency Use Authorization had a stronger adverse effect on willingness to vaccinate among older Americans and women. Democrats were more sensitive to vaccine efficacy than Republicans, and both groups responded differently to various endorsements of the vaccine. We also explored whether past flu vaccination history, attitudes toward general vaccine safety, and personal contact with severe cases of Covid-19 can explain variation in group vaccination hesitancy. Many subgroups that exhibit the greatest Covid-19 vaccine hesitancy did not report significantly lower frequencies of flu vaccination. Several groups that exhibited greater Covid-19 vaccine hesitancy also reported greater concerns about vaccine safety generally, but others did not. Finally, subgroup variation in reported personal contact with severe cases of Covid-19 did not strongly match subgroup variation in vaccine acceptance.
公共卫生官员警告称,广泛接种新冠疫苗的最大障碍不是科学或技术方面的,而是公众对新型疫苗存在较大的犹豫。了解影响疫苗接种的因素对于开展公共卫生活动、消除公众顾虑并确保广泛接种至关重要。我们通过一项在线调查(调查对象为近 2000 名美国成年人)中的联合实验发现,七种疫苗属性对研究对象接种疫苗意愿的影响在不同亚组中存在显著差异。疫苗有效性对白人接种疫苗的意愿影响明显大于对黑人的影响,而疫苗获得美国食品和药物管理局(FDA)紧急使用授权(EUA)对老年人群体和女性接种疫苗的意愿有更强的负面影响。与共和党人相比,民主党人对疫苗效力更敏感,两党对疫苗的各种支持也有不同的反应。我们还探讨了过去流感疫苗接种史、对一般疫苗安全性的态度以及与新冠重症病例的个人接触是否可以解释群体疫苗犹豫的差异。许多表现出最大新冠疫苗犹豫的亚组并未报告流感疫苗接种频率明显较低。一些表现出更大新冠疫苗犹豫的群体通常也对疫苗安全性表示更大的担忧,但其他群体则没有。最后,报告的与新冠重症病例的个人接触亚组差异与疫苗接种接受度亚组差异并不完全匹配。