Watari Takashi, Hlaing Tin Myo, Kanda Hideyuki
General Medicine Center, Shimane University Hospital, Shimane, JPN.
Healthcare Quality and Safety, Harvard Medical School, Boston, USA.
Cureus. 2021 Apr 7;13(4):e14342. doi: 10.7759/cureus.14342.
Recently, the "Choosing Wisely" initiative has gained traction and high-value care has garnered attention. However, the actual situation of high-value care is different between developed and developing countries. To elucidate this, we highlight the differences between the high-value care provided by healthcare systems in Japan and Myanmar, as representations of developed and developing countries, respectively. Despite the total numbers of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) equipment in Japan being 400 times higher than in Myanmar, and gross domestic product per capita being 32 times higher in Japan, the individual costs (out of pocket expenditures) per MRI scan are the same (USD 60). However, the total cost per MRI scan is different, implying that differing healthcare costs indicate the existence of over- and under-diagnosis problems among different countries. This study suggests that detailed patient histories and physical examinations are important for selecting relevant diagnostic imaging and reducing unnecessary imaging.
最近,“明智选择”倡议得到了广泛关注,高价值医疗也备受瞩目。然而,发达国家和发展中国家高价值医疗的实际情况有所不同。为阐明这一点,我们分别以日本和缅甸的医疗体系为例,突出发达国家和发展中国家高价值医疗的差异。尽管日本的磁共振成像(MRI)设备总数比缅甸高400倍,日本的人均国内生产总值是缅甸的32倍,但每次MRI扫描的个人费用(自付费用)相同(60美元)。然而,每次MRI扫描的总成本却不同,这意味着不同的医疗成本表明不同国家存在过度诊断和诊断不足的问题。本研究表明,详细的患者病史和体格检查对于选择相关的诊断成像以及减少不必要的成像至关重要。