Alves Ricardo, Lopes Carla, Perelman Julian
NOVA National School of Public Health, Universidade NOVA de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal.
Comprehensive Health Research Center (CHRC), Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública, Universidade NOVA de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal.
Eur J Clin Nutr. 2022 Jan;76(1):134-142. doi: 10.1038/s41430-021-00926-1. Epub 2021 May 13.
Food subsidies for healthier foods and higher taxes for less healthy alternatives have been increasingly used to promote a healthy diet. Yet, some have argued that the fiscal burden on unhealthy products would fall disproportionately on the worse-off, raising equity concerns. This study estimates the association between income and the consumption of key food groups linked to the Mediterranean diet in the adult Portuguese population.
We used data from the Portuguese National Food, Nutrition and Physical Activity Survey (IAN-AF 2015-2016), which observed the daily diet of individuals aged above 18 and below 79 years old (n = 3242). Logistic regression models were used to estimate the magnitude of the association between self-reported household income categories and consumption of foods related to the Mediterranean diet (fish, vegetables, fruits and legumes), and not (sweets, sugar-sweetened beverages, cakes & pastries and processed meats). Stratified analyses were performed by education and age categories.
We observed that the intake of fish (35.8 vs 38.8 g p = 0.02), vegetables (146.7 vs 166.2 g p < 0.01), and fruits (119.8 vs 150.1 g p < 0.01) was positively related to income, with a clear gradient for the two latter. Yet, the positive income-consumption link for fish was only observed among low-educated people, and the one for legumes among high educated and youths. Conversely, the consumption of most non-Mediterranean foods was not positively related to income categories, with the exception of sweets (34.8 vs 31.8 g p = 0.01) and cakes (26.4 vs 21.4 g p < 0.01) (more prevalent among the better-off).
The consumption of healthy food is mostly consistently related to income, contrary to the intake of unhealthy ones. It may well be, therefore, that subsidies to healthy foods could allow access to the worse-off while taxing unhealthy food will not impose a disproportionate burden on them.
对健康食品的补贴以及对不健康食品替代品征收更高的税,已越来越多地用于促进健康饮食。然而,一些人认为,对不健康产品的财政负担将不成比例地落在较贫困人群身上,引发了对公平性的担忧。本研究估计了葡萄牙成年人群收入与与地中海饮食相关的主要食物组消费之间的关联。
我们使用了葡萄牙全国食品、营养与身体活动调查(IAN - AF 2015 - 2016)的数据,该调查观察了18岁以上和79岁以下个体的日常饮食(n = 3242)。逻辑回归模型用于估计自我报告的家庭收入类别与地中海饮食相关食物(鱼类、蔬菜、水果和豆类)以及非相关食物(甜食、含糖饮料、蛋糕和糕点以及加工肉类)消费之间关联的程度。按教育程度和年龄类别进行分层分析。
我们观察到,鱼类(35.8克对38.8克,p = 0.02)、蔬菜(146.7克对166.2克,p < 0.01)和水果(119.8克对150.1克,p < 0.01)的摄入量与收入呈正相关,后两者呈现明显的梯度关系。然而,鱼类的收入 - 消费正相关仅在低教育人群中观察到,豆类的正相关则在高学历人群和年轻人中观察到。相反,大多数非地中海食物的消费与收入类别没有正相关关系,甜食(34.8克对31.8克,p = 0.01)和蛋糕(26.4克对21.4克,p < 0.01)除外(在较富裕人群中更普遍)。
与不健康食品的摄入量相反,健康食品的消费大多与收入持续相关。因此,对健康食品的补贴可能使较贫困人群能够获得这些食品,而对不健康食品征税不会给他们带来不成比例的负担。