Bitter Cindy C, Patel Neej, Hinyard Leslie
Surgery, Division of Emergency Medicine, Saint Louis University School of Medicine, St. Louis, USA.
Medicine, College of Human Medicine, Michigan State University, East Lansing, USA.
Cureus. 2021 Apr 11;13(4):e14419. doi: 10.7759/cureus.14419.
The public has unrealistic views regarding the success of cardiopulmonary resuscitation, and one potential source of misinformation is medical dramas. Prior research has shown that depictions of resuscitation on television are skewed towards younger patients with acute injuries, while most cardiac arrests occur in older patients as a result of medical comorbidities. Additionally, the success rate of televised resuscitations on older shows has vastly exceeded good outcomes in the real world. We sought to understand resuscitation outcomes on current medical dramas and to review the literature for evidence that media affects patient decision-making. We reviewed medical dramas to evaluate the demographics of cardiac arrest victims and the success rate of resuscitations and compared the results to outcomes for real-world patients. Medical dramas continue to focus on trauma as the main cause of cardiac arrest and portray favorable outcomes more frequently than should be expected. Patients who believe the overly optimistic prognoses portrayed on television may be more likely to desire aggressive medical care in the face of serious illness. Healthcare workers should anticipate the need to counter misinformation when discussing patient goals of care and end-of-life planning.
公众对心肺复苏的成功率持有不切实际的看法,而一个潜在的错误信息来源是医疗剧。先前的研究表明,电视上对复苏的描绘偏向于患有急性损伤的年轻患者,而大多数心脏骤停发生在患有内科合并症的老年患者中。此外,早期电视剧中复苏成功的几率远远超过了现实世界中的良好结果。我们试图了解当前医疗剧中的复苏结果,并查阅文献以寻找媒体影响患者决策的证据。我们回顾了医疗剧,以评估心脏骤停受害者的人口统计学特征和复苏成功率,并将结果与现实世界患者的结果进行比较。医疗剧继续将创伤作为心脏骤停的主要原因,并且描绘的良好结果比预期更为频繁。那些相信电视上过于乐观的预后的患者,在面对严重疾病时可能更倾向于积极的医疗护理。医护人员在讨论患者的护理目标和临终计划时,应预见到有必要纠正错误信息。