Kip Hanneke, Da Silva Marcia C, Bouman Yvonne H A, van Gemert-Pijnen Lisette J E W C, Kelders Saskia M
Centre for eHealth and Wellbeing Research, Department of Psychology, Health & Technology, University of Twente, Enschede, the Netherlands.
Department of Research, Stichting Transfore, Deventer, the Netherlands.
Internet Interv. 2021 Apr 20;25:100392. doi: 10.1016/j.invent.2021.100392. eCollection 2021 Sep.
Research has shown that self-control training (SCT) is an effective intervention to increase self-control and behaviour driven by self-control, such as reactive aggression. We developed an app that offers SCT by asking users to use their non-dominant hand for daily tasks, and aimed to examine whether participants that received SCT via app or e-mail, and received either one daily task or five tasks at once, improved more in self-control and decreased in aggression compared to each other and a control group.
The design of this study was based on a pilot study in which a first version of the SCT app was developed and tested with students via a pretest-posttest design. Based on the outcomes of the pilot study, a 2 × 2 full factorial design ( = 204) with control group ( = 69) was used, with delivery via e-mail versus app and receiving one daily task versus five at once as factors. During four measuring points, self-control was assessed via the Brief Self-Control Scale (BSCS) and the Go/No-Go task, aggression was assessed using the Brief Aggression Questionnaire (BAQ). In the final questionnaire, open-ended questions were asked to gain insight into the app's points of improvement. Quantitative data were analysed using repeated measures linear mixed models, qualitative data were analysed via inductive coding.
While no interaction effects were found, analyses showed that only the BSCS-scores of participants that used the app significantly improved over time (F[3, 196.315] = 4.090, = .008), no improvements were observed in the e-mail and control condition. No meaningful differences in aggression, the Go/No-Go task, and between the one- and five-task conditions and control groups were found. Qualitative data showed that while the opinions on SCT-tasks differed, participants were overall satisfied with the intervention, but wanted more reminders.
The results of this study showed that an SCT app has the potential to bolster self-control. No convincing effects on aggression were found in this student sample, which might be explained by the relatively low levels of aggression in this target group. Consequently, the app should also be investigated in populations with aggression regulation problems. Future research might also focus on the use of SCT to improve other types of behaviour driven by self-control, such as physical activity or smoking. Finally, a more personalized version of the app, in which users can select the number and types of SCT-tasks, should be developed and evaluated.
研究表明,自我控制训练(SCT)是一种有效的干预措施,可增强自我控制能力以及由自我控制驱动的行为,如反应性攻击行为。我们开发了一款应用程序,通过要求用户使用非优势手完成日常任务来提供自我控制训练,并旨在研究通过应用程序或电子邮件接受自我控制训练,且一次接收一项日常任务或五项任务的参与者,与彼此以及一个对照组相比,在自我控制方面是否有更大改善以及攻击性是否降低。
本研究的设计基于一项试点研究,在该试点研究中开发了自我控制训练应用程序的第一版,并通过前测-后测设计对学生进行了测试。基于试点研究的结果,采用了一个2×2全因子设计(n = 204),设有对照组(n = 69),将通过电子邮件与应用程序交付以及一次接收一项日常任务与一次接收五项任务作为因素。在四个测量点,通过简短自我控制量表(BSCS)和停止信号任务评估自我控制能力,使用简短攻击问卷(BAQ)评估攻击性。在最终问卷中,提出了开放式问题以深入了解应用程序的改进点。定量数据使用重复测量线性混合模型进行分析,定性数据通过归纳编码进行分析。
虽然未发现交互效应,但分析表明,只有使用该应用程序的参与者的BSCS分数随时间显著提高(F[3, 196.315] = 4.090,p = 0.008),在电子邮件和对照组条件下未观察到改善。在攻击性、停止信号任务以及一项任务与五项任务条件和对照组之间未发现有意义的差异。定性数据表明,虽然对自我控制训练任务的看法存在差异,但参与者总体上对干预感到满意,但希望得到更多提醒。
本研究结果表明,一款自我控制训练应用程序有增强自我控制能力的潜力。在这个学生样本中未发现对攻击性有令人信服的影响,这可能是由于该目标群体中的攻击性水平相对较低。因此,也应该在有攻击行为调节问题的人群中对该应用程序进行研究。未来的研究还可以关注使用自我控制训练来改善其他由自我控制驱动的行为类型,如体育活动或吸烟。最后,应该开发并评估一个更个性化的应用程序版本,用户可以在其中选择自我控制训练任务的数量和类型。