Pekurinen Virve, Willman Laura, Virtanen Marianna, Kivimäki Mika, Vahtera Jussi, Välimäki Maritta
Department of Nursing Science, University of Turku, 20520 Turku, Finland.
Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, 00250 Helsinki, Finland.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2017 Oct 18;14(10):1245. doi: 10.3390/ijerph14101245.
Wellbeing of nurses is associated with patient aggression. Little is known about the differences in these associations between nurses working in different specialties. We aimed to estimate and compare the prevalence of patient aggression and the associations between patient aggression and the wellbeing of nurses in psychiatric and non-psychiatric specialties (medical and surgical, and emergency medicine). A sample of 5288 nurses (923 psychiatric nurses, 4070 medical and surgical nurses, 295 emergency nurses) participated in the study. Subjective measures were used to assess both the occurrence of patient aggression and the wellbeing of nurses (self-rated health, sleep disturbances, psychological distress and perceived work ability). Binary logistic regression with interaction terms was used to compare the associations between patient aggression and the wellbeing of nurses. Psychiatric nurses reported all types of patient aggression more frequently than medical and surgical nurses, whereas nurses working in emergency settings reported physical violence and verbal aggression more frequently than psychiatric nurses. Psychiatric nurses reported poor self-rated health and reduced work ability more frequently than both of the non-psychiatric nursing groups, whereas medical and surgical nurses reported psychological distress and sleep disturbances more often. Psychiatric nurses who had experienced at least one type of patient aggression or mental abuse in the previous year, were less likely to suffer from psychological distress and sleep disturbances compared to medical and surgical nurses. Psychiatric nurses who had experienced physical assaults and armed threats were less likely to suffer from sleep disturbances compared to nurses working in emergency settings. Compared to medical and surgical nurses, psychiatric nurses face patient aggression more often, but certain types of aggression are more common in emergency settings. Psychiatric nurses have worse subjective health and work ability than both of the non-psychiatric nursing groups, while their psychiatric wellbeing is better and they have less sleep problems compared to medical and surgical nurses. Psychiatric nurses maintain better psychiatric wellbeing and experience fewer sleep problems than non-psychiatric nurses after events of exposure to patient aggression. This suggest that more attention should be given to non-psychiatric settings for maintaining the wellbeing of nurses after exposure to patient aggression.
护士的幸福感与患者攻击行为相关。对于不同专科的护士在这些关联方面的差异,我们知之甚少。我们旨在评估和比较患者攻击行为的发生率,以及精神科和非精神科专科(内科、外科和急诊医学)中患者攻击行为与护士幸福感之间的关联。5288名护士(923名精神科护士、4070名内科和外科护士、295名急诊护士)参与了该研究。采用主观测量方法来评估患者攻击行为的发生情况以及护士的幸福感(自我评估健康状况、睡眠障碍、心理困扰和感知工作能力)。使用带有交互项的二元逻辑回归来比较患者攻击行为与护士幸福感之间的关联。精神科护士报告的各类患者攻击行为比内科和外科护士更频繁,而在急诊环境中工作的护士报告身体暴力和言语攻击比精神科护士更频繁。精神科护士报告自我评估健康状况差和工作能力下降比两个非精神科护理组都更频繁,而内科和外科护士报告心理困扰和睡眠障碍更频繁。与内科和外科护士相比,上一年经历过至少一种患者攻击行为或精神虐待的精神科护士遭受心理困扰和睡眠障碍的可能性较小。与在急诊环境中工作的护士相比,经历过身体攻击和武装威胁的精神科护士遭受睡眠障碍的可能性较小。与内科和外科护士相比,精神科护士更常面临患者攻击行为,但某些类型的攻击行为在急诊环境中更常见。精神科护士的主观健康状况和工作能力比两个非精神科护理组都差,而与内科和外科护士相比,他们的精神幸福感更好,睡眠问题更少。在经历患者攻击行为事件后,精神科护士的精神幸福感保持得更好,睡眠问题也比非精神科护士少。这表明在患者攻击行为事件后,应更多关注非精神科环境中护士幸福感的维护。