White Alexandre, Hao Lingxin, Yu Xiao, Thorpe Roland J
Johns Hopkins University and Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, United States.
Johns Hopkins University, United States.
EClinicalMedicine. 2021 Apr 25;35:100840. doi: 10.1016/j.eclinm.2021.100840. eCollection 2021 May.
Our objective is to examine whether residential racial segregation may be constraining capacities for social distancing thus leaving African Americans potentially more exposed to contracting COVID-19. We hypothesized that residential racial segregation constrains African Americans' spatial mobility when the whole population is locked down but increases their need for moving under reopening orders.
We employ a Black/White dissimilarity index as our independent variable and county-level mobility ratios as our dependent variable. Using generalized estimating equations for longitudinal data, we analyzed the effects of Black/White segregation on population mobility by counties across the United States from March 8 to August 7, 2020 under two different COVID-19 related policy conditions: lockdown and reopening.
While higher county-wide levels of segregation were significantly associated with decreased mobility under lockdown and stay-at-home orders, we found that this relationship between segregation and mobility dissipated under reopening orders.
Investigating the effects of health policy without considering differing effects due to structural racism will likely ignore complexities that may create unintended consequences of health policy. Our conclusions suggest African Americans may face structural limitations to effective social distancing as evidenced by higher rates of mobility after reopening policies go into effect.
我们的目标是研究居住种族隔离是否可能限制社交距离的能力,从而使非裔美国人更容易感染新冠病毒。我们假设,在整个社会实施封锁时,居住种族隔离会限制非裔美国人的空间流动性,但在重新开放的命令下,他们的出行需求会增加。
我们使用黑/白差异指数作为自变量,县级流动率作为因变量。利用纵向数据的广义估计方程,我们分析了2020年3月8日至8月7日期间,在两种不同的与新冠病毒相关的政策条件下(封锁和重新开放),美国各县黑/白隔离对人口流动的影响。
虽然全县范围内较高的隔离水平与封锁和居家令下流动性的降低显著相关,但我们发现,在重新开放的命令下,隔离与流动性之间的这种关系消失了。
在不考虑结构性种族主义不同影响的情况下研究卫生政策的效果,可能会忽略那些可能导致卫生政策产生意外后果的复杂性。我们的结论表明,重新开放政策生效后非裔美国人较高的流动率证明,他们在进行有效社交距离方面可能面临结构性限制。