Department of Biobehavioral Sciences, Teachers College, Columbia University, New York, NY.
Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 2021 Jun 18;30(3S):1446-1458. doi: 10.1044/2021_AJSLP-20-00141. Epub 2021 May 19.
Purpose This retrospective pilot study investigated whether sound-level and speech production errors decreased in confrontation naming following Verb Network Strengthening Treatment (VNeST) for four participants with acquired apraxia of speech (A-AOS) and aphasia for whom lexical retrieval was previously reported. Specifically, we investigated a potential increase in correct number of syllables per word and posttreatment changes across three domains of speech: segmental production, fluency, and prosody. It was hypothesized that treatment shown to increase lexical retrieval in persons with aphasia and A-AOS could potentially facilitate a reduction in sound-level and speech production errors consistent with dual diagnoses of A-AOS and aphasia. Method Naming responses from four participants with aphasia and A-AOS who previously participated in VNeST studies were investigated for correct number of syllables per word and measures of segmental speech, fluency, and prosody. Results Significant gains in at least one measure of speech production were reported for three of the participants. One participant demonstrated decreased segmental speech errors, two showed significant reduction on syllable segmentation, and two demonstrated a significant reduction on false starts and pauses. Significant gains in production of correct number of syllables were limited to one participant, and one participant did not demonstrate increased accuracy on any measure of speech production. Conclusions While speech production errors consistent with motor speech impairment cannot always be definitively distinguished from the confound of aphasia, two participants produced significantly decreased segmentation of syllables, a characteristic unique to A-AOS. The sound-level and speech production changes recorded may be attributed to a combination of interacting motor and language processes and resource allocation. In addition, specific components of VNeST may have contributed to speech production changes. Future work will focus on a prospective study of effects of language therapy (e.g., VNeST) on measures of speech production with investigation beyond the single-word level.
本回顾性初步研究旨在调查针对四名患有获得性运动性言语障碍(A-AOS)和言语失用症的患者进行的动词网络强化治疗(VNeST)后,在命名任务中,言语声级和言语产生错误是否减少。具体而言,我们研究了言语的三个领域(音段产生、流畅度和韵律)中每个词的正确音节数和治疗后变化的潜在增加:音段产生、流畅度和韵律。假设先前显示能增加言语失用症和 A-AOS 患者词汇检索的治疗方法可能有助于减少与 A-AOS 和言语失用症的双重诊断一致的言语声级和言语产生错误。
对先前参加过 VNeST 研究的 4 名患有言语失用症和 A-AOS 的患者的命名反应进行研究,以确定每个词的正确音节数和音段言语、流畅度和韵律的测量。
对于其中 3 名患者,至少有一个言语产生测量值的显著改善。一名患者表现出音段言语错误减少,2 名患者音节分段的显著减少,2 名患者出现显著减少的起始错误和停顿。只有一名患者表现出产生正确音节数的显著增加,而一名患者在任何言语产生测量上都没有表现出准确性增加。
虽然与运动性言语障碍一致的言语产生错误不能总是与失语症的混杂因素明确区分,但有两名患者表现出音节分段的显著减少,这是 A-AOS 的特征。记录的言语声级和言语产生变化可能归因于相互作用的运动和语言过程以及资源分配的结合。此外,VNeST 的特定成分可能促成了言语产生的变化。未来的工作将集中在对语言治疗(例如,VNeST)对言语产生测量的影响进行前瞻性研究,研究范围超出单字水平。