Shaw Lisa, Graziadio Sara, Lendrem Clare, Dale Nicholas, Ford Gary A, Roffe Christine, Smith Craig J, White Philip M, Price Christopher I
Stroke Research Group, Population Health Sciences Institute, Newcastle University, Henry Wellcome Building, Newcastle Upon Tyne, NE2 4HH, UK.
NIHR Newcastle In Vitro Diagnostics Co-operative, Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Royal Victoria Infirmary, Queen Victoria Road, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE1 4LP, UK.
Diagn Progn Res. 2021 May 20;5(1):11. doi: 10.1186/s41512-021-00098-3.
Rapid treatment of stroke improves outcomes, but accurate early recognition can be challenging. Between 20 and 40% of patients suspected to have stroke by ambulance and emergency department staff later receive a non-stroke 'mimic' diagnosis after stroke specialist investigation. This early diagnostic uncertainty results in displacement of mimic patients from more appropriate services, inappropriate demands on stroke specialist resources and delayed access to specialist therapies for stroke patients. Blood purine concentrations rise rapidly during hypoxic tissue injury, which is a key mechanism of damage during acute stroke but is not typical in mimic conditions. A portable point of care fingerprick test has been developed to measure blood purine concentration which could be used to triage patients experiencing suspected stroke symptoms into those likely to have a non-stroke mimic condition and those likely to have true stroke. This study is evaluating test performance for identification of stroke mimic conditions.
Design: prospective observational cohort study Setting: regional UK ambulance and acute stroke services Participants: a convenience series of two populations will be tested: adults with a label of suspected stroke assigned (and tested) by attending ambulance personnel and adults with a label of suspected stroke assigned at hospital (who have not been tested by ambulance staff).
SMARTChip Purine assay Reference standard tests: expert clinician opinion informed by brain imaging and/or other investigations will assign the following diagnoses which constitute the suspected stroke population: ischaemic stroke, haemorrhagic stroke, TIA and stroke mimic conditions.
ambulance population (powered for mimic sensitivity) 935 participants; hospital population (powered for mimic specificity) 377 participants.
area under the receiver operating curve (ROC) and optimal sensitivity, specificity, and negative and positive predictive values for identification of mimic conditions. Optimal threshold for the ambulance population will maximise sensitivity, minimum 80%, and aim to keep specificity above 70%. Optimal threshold for the hospital population will maximise specificity, minimum 80%, and aim to keep sensitivity above 70%.
The results from this study will determine how accurately the SMARTChip purine assay test can identify stroke mimic conditions within the suspected stroke population. If acceptable performance is confirmed, deployment of the test in ambulances or emergency departments could enable more appropriate direction of patients to stroke or non-stroke services.
Registered with ISRCTN (identifier: ISRCTN22323981) on 13/02/2019 http://www.isrctn.com/ISRCTN22323981.
中风的快速治疗可改善预后,但准确的早期识别具有挑战性。在被救护车和急诊科工作人员怀疑患有中风的患者中,有20%至40%在经过中风专科检查后,后来被诊断为非中风“模仿症”。这种早期诊断的不确定性导致模仿症患者被从更合适的服务中转移出来,对中风专科资源提出了不适当的需求,并延误了中风患者获得专科治疗的机会。在缺氧性组织损伤期间,血液嘌呤浓度会迅速升高,这是急性中风期间损伤的关键机制,但在模仿症情况下并不常见。现已开发出一种便携式即时护理指尖采血检测方法来测量血液嘌呤浓度,该方法可用于对出现疑似中风症状的患者进行分类,区分哪些患者可能患有非中风模仿症,哪些患者可能患有真正的中风。本研究正在评估该检测方法在识别中风模仿症方面的性能。
设计:前瞻性观察队列研究 地点:英国地区救护车和急性中风服务机构 参与者:将对两组便利样本人群进行检测:一组是被出诊救护车人员贴上疑似中风标签(并进行检测)的成年人,另一组是在医院被贴上疑似中风标签的成年人(未经过救护车工作人员检测)。
SMARTChip嘌呤检测法 参考标准检测:由脑成像和/或其他检查得出的专家临床意见将给出以下诊断,这些诊断构成疑似中风人群:缺血性中风、出血性中风、短暂性脑缺血发作和中风模仿症。
救护车人群(针对模仿症敏感性进行效能分析)935名参与者;医院人群(针对模仿症特异性进行效能分析)377名参与者。
受试者工作特征曲线(ROC)下面积以及用于识别模仿症的最佳敏感性、特异性、阴性和阳性预测值。救护车人群的最佳阈值将使敏感性最大化,最低为80%,并力求使特异性保持在70%以上。医院人群的最佳阈值将使特异性最大化,最低为80%,并力求使敏感性保持在70%以上。
本研究结果将确定SMARTChip嘌呤检测法在疑似中风人群中识别中风模仿症的准确程度。如果证实该检测方法性能可接受,那么在救护车或急诊科部署该检测方法可使患者更合理地被引导至中风或非中风服务机构。
于2019年2月13日在国际标准随机对照试验编号注册库(标识符:ISRCTN22323981)注册 http://www.isrctn.com/ISRCTN22323981 。