Arakawa Naoko, Bruno-Tomé Andreia, Bates Ian
School of Pharmacy, University of Nottingham, UK.
Faculty of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences, Monash University, Australia.
Innov Pharm. 2020 Mar 17;11(1). doi: 10.24926/iip.v11i1.2093. eCollection 2020.
Time-tabled curricular contents and syllabi reflect the actual delivery of the academic programme and one of key quality components in healthcare professional education. There is a need of global evidence base of Initial Pharmacy Education and Training (IPET) curricula for assisting the advancement of IPET globally.
To seek the differences and similarities among IPET curricula and to explore relative trends and weighting of IPET curricula globally.
Sample curricular documents were collected purposively either through a parallel survey study investigating the structures and processes of IPET globally in collaboration with the International Pharmaceutical Federation Education (FIPEd), or through research team network. Collected textual documents containing IPET curricular contents were analysed by a mixed approach of the comparative content and framework analyses, using curriculum clusters in a guideline from the PHARMINE project.
IPET curricular documents were collected from 16 countries and territories. The study showed study years spent in the IPET years range from four to six years, and a sample mean of average syllabus time spent per year is 728 hours/year (excluding outlier). There was a biggest variance in the pharmacy practice cluster (PRAC) among samples, ranging from 49.3 to 12.8%, showing a significant negative correlation with the chemical science cluster (CHEM) a = -0.77 (p<.0001). Categorised further into three curricular content groups, the study identified that there was variances in a tendency of the curricular orientation of science or practice-focus between countries.
The study allowed a first global comparison of IPET curricula from all WHO regions, which provided a better understanding of current IPET practice and delivery across nations and established evidence base to address challenges and gaps for further improvement of IPET curriculum in any country.
课程表中的教学内容和教学大纲反映了学术项目的实际授课情况,是医疗保健专业教育的关键质量要素之一。需要建立全球初始药学教育与培训(IPET)课程的证据库,以助力全球IPET的发展。
探寻IPET课程之间的异同,探索全球IPET课程的相关趋势和权重。
通过与国际药学联合会教育委员会(FIPEd)合作开展的一项关于全球IPET结构和流程的平行调查研究,或通过研究团队网络,有目的地收集样本课程文件。使用PHARMINE项目指南中的课程集群,通过比较内容分析和框架分析的混合方法,对收集到的包含IPET课程内容的文本文件进行分析。
从16个国家和地区收集了IPET课程文件。研究表明,IPET阶段的学习年限为4至6年,样本中每年平均教学大纲时间的均值为728小时/年(不包括异常值)。样本中,药学实践集群(PRAC)的差异最大,范围为49.3%至12.8%,与化学科学集群(CHEM)呈显著负相关,a = -0.77(p<.0001)。进一步分为三个课程内容组后,研究发现不同国家在科学或实践导向的课程倾向方面存在差异。
该研究首次对世卫组织所有区域的IPET课程进行了全球比较,有助于更好地了解各国当前的IPET实践和授课情况,并为应对挑战和弥补差距奠定了证据基础,以进一步完善任何国家的IPET课程。