Instituto Nacional de Investigaciones Forestales, Agrícolas y Pecuarias, Campo Experimental Edzná, Carretera Campeche-Pocyaxum km 17.5, C.P. 24000, Campeche, Campeche, Mexico.
Escuela Superior de Ciencias Agropecuarias, Universidad Autónoma de Campeche, Calle 53 S/N, Col. Unidad, Esfuerzo y Trabajo #2. C.P. 24350, Escárcega, Campeche, Mexico.
Vet Parasitol Reg Stud Reports. 2021 Apr;24:100549. doi: 10.1016/j.vprsr.2021.100549. Epub 2021 Mar 3.
The present study explored the frequency of hair-sheep farms with gastrointestinal nematodes (GIN) resistant to albendazole sulfoxide (AS), ivermectin (IVM) and levamisole (LEV) in the Yucatán peninsula, México, using the faecal egg count reduction test (FECRT), and compared the frequency of farms diagnosed with resistance using three different formulae. The survey included farms from the states of Campeche (9) and Yucatán (14) (2016-2019). Collaborating farms had >100 grazing ewes. Animals in the FECRT were > 12 months old, received no anthelmintic for >8 weeks and had ≥150 GIN eggs per gramme of faeces (EPG). Animals were distributed to respective groups: untreated controls, AS (5 mg/kg BW), IVM (0.2 mg/kg BW), and LEV (7.5 mg/kg BW). Due to low EPG, some farms only included one or two AH groups. Second faecal samples were obtained on day 14 post-treatment to estimate the percentage reduction (%R) and 95% confidence interval (95%CI). Criteria to declare resistance were those proposed by the World Association for the Advancement of Veterinary Parasitology. Three formulae were used to estimate resistance frequency: The RESO© and eggCounts-T:C, which considered treated and control EPG means post-treatment, but differed in their 95%CI estimation, while the eggCounts-T:T only considered pre- and post-treatment EPG means with 95%CI. The RESO© and eggCounts-T:C formulae resulted in the same frequency of IVM resistant farms for Campeche (100%; 9/9) and Yucatán (92.9%; 13/14), while, the eggCount-T:T formula resulted in a frequency of 85.7% (12/14) IVM resistance in Yucatán. The three formulae estimated the same frequency of AS resistant farms in Campeche (100%; 9/9) and Yucatán (87.5%; 7/8). The RESO© and the eggCounts-T:C formulae resulted in the same frequency of LEV resistant farms for Campeche (44.4%; 4/9), and Yucatán (60.0%; 6/10), but the eggCounts-T:T formula resulted in a frequency of 40.0% (4/10) LEV resistance in Yucatán. The FECRT using RESO© or eggCounts-T:C formulae are stricter than the eggCounts-T:T as the latter cannot identify what proportion of the %R cannot be attributed to the AH. The untreated control group helped adjusting the %R calculation and seemed more adequate considering the propensity of hair-sheep to reduce their EPG on their own. .
本研究采用粪便卵囊减少试验(FECRT),探讨了墨西哥尤卡坦半岛对阿苯达唑亚砜(AS)、伊维菌素(IVM)和左旋咪唑(LEV)具有胃肠道线虫(GIN)耐药性的绵羊养殖场的频率,并比较了使用三种不同公式诊断耐药性的养殖场频率。该调查包括来自坎佩切州(9 个)和尤卡坦州(14 个)的农场(2016-2019 年)。合作农场有 >100 只放牧绵羊。FECRT 中的动物 >12 个月大,>8 周未使用驱虫药,每克粪便中的 GIN 卵数(EPG)≥150 个。动物被分配到各自的组:未处理的对照组、AS(5 mg/kg BW)、IVM(0.2 mg/kg BW)和 LEV(7.5 mg/kg BW)。由于 EPG 较低,一些农场只包括一个或两个 AH 组。在治疗后第 14 天获得第二次粪便样本,以估计百分比减少(%R)和 95%置信区间(95%CI)。耐药性的判定标准是世界兽医寄生虫学进步协会提出的标准。使用了三种公式来估计耐药频率:RESO©和 eggCounts-T:C,它们考虑了治疗后和对照组的 EPG 平均值,但在其 95%CI 估计方面有所不同,而 eggCounts-T:T 仅考虑了治疗前和治疗后的 EPG 平均值及其 95%CI。RESO©和 eggCounts-T:C 公式导致坎佩切州(100%;9/9)和尤卡坦州(92.9%;13/14)的 IVM 耐药农场的频率相同,而 eggCount-T:T 公式导致尤卡坦州 IVM 耐药率为 85.7%(12/14)。三种公式估计坎佩切州(100%;9/9)和尤卡坦州(87.5%;7/8)的 AS 耐药农场的频率相同。RESO©和 eggCounts-T:C 公式导致坎佩切州(44.4%;4/9)和尤卡坦州(60.0%;6/10)的 LEV 耐药农场的频率相同,但 eggCounts-T:T 公式导致尤卡坦州的 LEV 耐药率为 40.0%(4/10)。使用 RESO©或 eggCounts-T:C 公式的 FECRT 比 eggCounts-T:T 更严格,因为后者无法识别 AH 无法解释的 %R 比例。未处理的对照组有助于调整 %R 的计算,并且考虑到绵羊自行降低 EPG 的倾向,似乎更合适。