Krücken Jürgen, Ehnert Paula, Fiedler Stefan, Horn Fabian, Helm Christina S, Ramünke Sabrina, Bartmann Tanja, Kahl Alexandra, Neubert Ann, Weiher Wiebke, Daher Ricarda, Terhalle Werner, Klabunde-Negatsch Alexandra, Steuber Stephan, von Samson-Himmelstjerna Georg
Institute for Parasitology and Tropical Veterinary Medicine, Freie Universität Berlin, Germany; Veterinary Centre for Resistance Research, Freie Universität Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
Federal Office of Consumer Protection and Food Safety, Berlin, Germany.
Int J Parasitol Drugs Drug Resist. 2024 Aug;25:100547. doi: 10.1016/j.ijpddr.2024.100547. Epub 2024 May 5.
Anthelmintic resistance in sheep parasitic gastrointestinal nematodes is widespread and a severe health and economic issue but prevalence of resistance and involved parasite species are unknown in Germany. Here, the faecal egg count reduction test (FECRT) was performed on eight farms using fenbendazole, ivermectin and moxidectin and on four farms using only moxidectin. A questionnaire was used to obtain data on management practices to potentially identify risk factors for presence of resistance. All requirements of the recently revised WAAVP guideline for diagnosing anthelmintic resistance using the FECRT were applied. Nematode species composition in pre- and post-treatment samples was analysed with the nemabiome approach. Using the eggCounts statistic package, resistance against fenbendazole, ivermectin and moxidectin was found on 7/8, 8/8 and 8/12 farms, respectively. No formal risk factor analysis was conducted since resistance was present on most farms. Comparison with the bayescount R package results revealed substantial agreement between methods (Cohen's κ = 0.774). In contrast, interpretation of data comparing revised and original WAAVP guidelines resulted in moderate agreement (Cohen's κ = 0.444). The FECR for moxidectin was significantly higher than for ivermectin and fenbendazole. Nemabiome data identified 4 to 12 species in pre-treatment samples and treatments caused a small but significant decrease in species diversity (inverse Simpson index). Non-metric multidimensional scaling and k-means clustering were used to identify common patterns in pre- and post-treatment samples. However, post-treatment samples were scattered among the pre-treatment samples. Resistant parasite species differed between farms. In conclusion, the revised FECRT guideline allows robust detection of anthelmintic resistance. Resistance was widespread and involved multiple parasite species. Resistance against both drug classes on the same farm was common. Further studies including additional drugs (levamisole, monepantel, closantel) should combine sensitive FECRTs with nemabiome data to comprehensively characterise the anthelmintic susceptibility status of sheep nematodes in Germany.
绵羊寄生性胃肠线虫的抗蠕虫药耐药性广泛存在,是一个严重的健康和经济问题,但德国的耐药性流行情况及相关寄生虫种类尚不清楚。在此,对8个使用芬苯达唑、伊维菌素和莫西菌素的农场以及4个仅使用莫西菌素的农场进行了粪便虫卵计数减少试验(FECRT)。使用问卷调查获取管理措施数据,以潜在识别耐药性存在的风险因素。应用了最近修订的世界动物寄生虫学协会(WAAVP)使用FECRT诊断抗蠕虫药耐药性指南的所有要求。采用线虫生物群落方法分析治疗前和治疗后样本中的线虫种类组成。使用eggCounts统计软件包,分别在7/8、8/8和8/12的农场中发现了对芬苯达唑、伊维菌素和莫西菌素的耐药性。由于大多数农场都存在耐药性,因此未进行正式的风险因素分析。与bayescount R软件包结果的比较显示,两种方法之间有实质性的一致性(科恩kappa系数=0.774)。相比之下,比较修订后的和原始的WAAVP指南的数据解释结果为中度一致(科恩kappa系数=0.444)。莫西菌素的FECR显著高于伊维菌素和芬苯达唑。线虫生物群落数据在治疗前样本中识别出4至12种,治疗导致物种多样性略有但显著下降(逆辛普森指数)。使用非度量多维标度法和k均值聚类法来识别治疗前和治疗后样本中的共同模式。然而,治疗后样本分散在治疗前样本中。不同农场的耐药寄生虫种类不同。总之,修订后的FECRT指南能够可靠地检测抗蠕虫药耐药性。耐药性广泛存在且涉及多种寄生虫种类。同一农场对两种药物类别的耐药性很常见。进一步的研究包括其他药物(左旋咪唑、莫能菌素、氯氰碘柳胺),应将敏感的FECRT与线虫生物群落数据相结合,以全面表征德国绵羊线虫的抗蠕虫药敏感性状况。