Hung Shao-Min, Hsieh Po-Jang
Division of Biology and Biological Engineering, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, USA.
Neuroscience and Behavioral Disorders Program, Duke-NUS Medical School, Singapore.
J Vis. 2021 May 3;21(5):27. doi: 10.1167/jov.21.5.27.
Whether unconscious complex visual information integration occurs over time remains largely unknown and highly controversial. Previous studies have tended to use a combination of strong masking or suppression and a weak stimulus signal (e.g., low luminance), resulting in a low signal-to-noise ratio during unconscious stimulus presentation. To lengthen the stimulus exposure, we introduced intermittent presentation into interocular suppression. This discontinuous suppression allowed us to insert a word during each suppression period and deliver multiple words over time unconsciously. We found that, after participants received the subliminal context, they responded faster to a syntactically incongruent target word in a lexical decision task. We later replicated the finding in a separate experiment where participants exhibited chance performance on locating the subliminal context. These results confirmed that the sentential context was both subjectively and objectively subliminal. Critically, the effect disappeared when the context was disrupted by presenting only partial sentences or sentences with a reversed word order. These control experiments showed that the effect was not merely driven by word-word association but instead required integration over multiple words in the correct order. These findings support the possibility of unconscious high-level, complex information integration.
随着时间的推移,无意识的复杂视觉信息整合是否会发生在很大程度上仍然未知且极具争议。以往的研究倾向于使用强掩蔽或抑制与弱刺激信号(如低亮度)相结合的方法,导致在无意识刺激呈现期间信噪比很低。为了延长刺激暴露时间,我们在双眼抑制中引入了间歇性呈现。这种不连续的抑制使我们能够在每个抑制期插入一个单词,并随着时间的推移无意识地传递多个单词。我们发现,在参与者接受阈下语境后,他们在词汇判断任务中对句法不一致的目标词反应更快。后来,我们在另一个实验中重复了这一发现,在该实验中参与者在定位阈下语境时表现出随机水平。这些结果证实,句子语境在主观和客观上都是阈下的。至关重要的是,当通过仅呈现部分句子或词序颠倒的句子来破坏语境时,这种效应就会消失。这些对照实验表明,这种效应不仅仅是由词与词的关联驱动的,而是需要以正确的顺序对多个单词进行整合。这些发现支持了无意识的高级复杂信息整合的可能性。