老年住院患者的抗胆碱能负担:从入院到出院的模式及其与医院结局的关联。

Anticholinergic burden in older adult inpatients: patterns from admission to discharge and associations with hospital outcomes.

作者信息

Herrero-Zazo Maria, Berry Rachel, Bines Emma, Bhattacharya Debi, Myint Phyo K, Keevil Victoria L

机构信息

European Molecular Biology Laboratory-European Bioinformatics Institute (EMBL-EBI), Hinxton, Cambridge, UK.

Pharmacy Department, Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Cambridge, UK.

出版信息

Ther Adv Drug Saf. 2021 May 6;12:20420986211012592. doi: 10.1177/20420986211012592. eCollection 2021.

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Anticholinergic medications are associated with adverse outcomes in older adults and should be prescribed cautiously. We describe the Anticholinergic Risk Scale (ARS) scores of older inpatients and associations with outcomes.

METHODS

We included all emergency, first admissions of adults ⩾65 years old admitted to one hospital over 4 years. Demographics, discharge specialty, dementia/history of cognitive concern, illness acuity and medications were retrieved from electronic records. ARS scores were calculated as the sum of anticholinergic potential for each medication (0 = limited/none; 1 = moderate; 2 = strong and 3 = very strong). We categorised patients based on admission ARS score [ARS = 0 (reference); ARS = 1; ARS = 2; ARS ⩾ 3] and change in ARS score from admission to discharge [admission and discharge ARS = 0 (reference); same; decreased; increased]. We described anticholinergic prescribing patterns by discharge specialty and explored multivariable associations between ARS score categories and mortality using logistic regression [odds ratios (ORs), 95% confidence intervals (CIs)].

RESULTS

From 33,360 patients, 10,183 (31%) were prescribed an anticholinergic medication on admission. Mean admission ARS scores were: Cardiology and Stroke = 0.56; General Medicine = 0.78; Geriatric Medicine = 0.83; Other medicine = 0.81; Trauma and Orthopaedics = 0.66; Other Surgery = 0.65. Mean ARS did not increase from admission to discharge in any specialty but reductions varied significantly, from 4.6% (Other Surgery) to 27.7% (Geriatric Medicine) ( < 0.001). The odds of both 30-day inpatient and 30-day post-discharge mortality increased with admission ARS = 1 (OR = 1.21, 95% CI 1.01-1.44 and OR = 1.44, 1.18-1.74) but not with ARS = 2 or ARS ⩾ 3. The odds of 30-day post-discharge mortality were higher in all ARS change categories, relative to no anticholinergic exposure (same: OR = 1.45, 1.21-1.74, decreased: OR = 1.27, 1.01-1.57, increased: OR = 2.48, 1.98-3.08).

CONCLUSION

The inconsistent dose-response associations with mortality may be due to confounding and measurement error which may be addressed by a prospective trial. Definitive evidence for this prevalent modifiable risk factor is required to support clinician behaviour-change, thus reducing variation in anticholinergic deprescribing by inpatient speciality.

PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY

: Medicines which block the chemical acetylcholine are commonly prescribed to treat symptoms such as itch and difficulty sleeping or to treat medical conditions such as depression. However, some studies in older adults have found potential links between these medicines and confusion and falls. Therefore, doctors are recommended to prescribe these drugs cautiously in adults aged 65 years and over. In our paper we use data collected as part of routine medical care at one university hospital to describe how often these medicines are prescribed in a large sample of older adults admitted to hospital as an emergency. We look at the medicines patients are prescribed on admission to the hospital and also when they are later discharged. We find that these medicines are frequently prescribed. We also find that, in general, patients are prescribed fewer of these potentially harmful medicines on hospital discharge compared with hospital admission. This suggests that clinicians are aware of advice to prescribe acetylcholine blocking medicines cautiously and they are more often stopped in hospital than started. However, we find a lot of variation in practice depending on which hospital specialty was caring for the patient during their inpatient stay. We also find potential links with these medicines and death during the admission or soon after hospital discharge, but these potential links are not always consistent. Further study is needed to fully understand links between medicines that block acetylcholine and late life health. This will be important to reduce variation in prescribing practices.

摘要

背景

抗胆碱能药物与老年人的不良后果相关,应谨慎开具处方。我们描述了老年住院患者的抗胆碱能风险量表(ARS)评分及其与预后的关联。

方法

我们纳入了4年间一家医院收治的所有65岁及以上成人的急诊首次入院患者。从电子记录中获取人口统计学信息、出院科室、痴呆/认知问题病史、疾病严重程度和用药情况。ARS评分计算为每种药物的抗胆碱能潜力之和(0 = 有限/无;1 = 中度;2 = 强效;3 = 极强效)。我们根据入院时的ARS评分[ARS = 0(参照);ARS = 1;ARS = 2;ARS ≥ 3]以及从入院到出院时ARS评分的变化[入院和出院时ARS = 0(参照);相同;降低;升高]对患者进行分类。我们按出院科室描述了抗胆碱能药物的处方模式,并使用逻辑回归[比值比(OR),95%置信区间(CI)]探讨了ARS评分类别与死亡率之间的多变量关联。

结果

在33360例患者中,10183例(31%)在入院时开具了抗胆碱能药物。入院时的平均ARS评分如下:心脏病学和中风科 = 0.56;普通内科 = 0.78;老年医学科 = 0.83;其他内科 = 0.81;创伤与骨科 = 0.66;其他外科 = 0.65。各科室从入院到出院时平均ARS评分均未升高,但降低幅度差异显著,从4.6%(其他外科)到27.7%(老年医学科)(P < 0.001)。入院时ARS = 1时,30天住院死亡率和30天出院后死亡率的比值均升高(OR = 1.21,95% CI 1.01 - 1.44和OR = 1.44,1.18 - 1.74),但ARS = 2或ARS ≥ 3时则不然。与未接触抗胆碱能药物相比,所有ARS变化类别中30天出院后死亡率的比值均较高(相同:OR = 1.45,1.21 - 1.74;降低:OR = 1.27,1.01 - 1.57;升高:OR = 2.48,1.98 - 3.08)。

结论

与死亡率不一致的剂量反应关联可能是由于混杂因素和测量误差导致的,前瞻性试验或许可以解决这些问题。需要确凿证据来支持这一普遍存在且可改变的风险因素,以促使临床医生改变行为,从而减少住院科室在停用抗胆碱能药物方面的差异。

通俗易懂的总结

阻断化学物质乙酰胆碱的药物通常用于治疗瘙痒、睡眠困难等症状或抑郁症等病症。然而,一些针对老年人的研究发现这些药物与意识混乱和跌倒之间存在潜在联系。因此,建议医生在65岁及以上成年人中谨慎开具这些药物。在我们的论文中,我们使用作为一所大学医院常规医疗护理一部分收集的数据,来描述在大量因急诊入院的老年患者样本中这些药物的开具频率。我们观察了患者入院时以及随后出院时所开具的药物。我们发现这些药物经常被开具。我们还发现,总体而言,与入院时相比,患者出院时所开具的这些潜在有害药物较少。这表明临床医生意识到了谨慎开具乙酰胆碱阻断药物的建议,而且这些药物在医院里更多是被停用而非启用。然而,我们发现在实际操作中存在很大差异,这取决于患者住院期间负责护理的医院科室。我们还发现这些药物与住院期间或出院后不久的死亡之间存在潜在联系,但这些潜在联系并不总是一致的。需要进一步研究以充分了解阻断乙酰胆碱的药物与晚年健康之间的联系。这对于减少处方实践中的差异将很重要。

https://cdn.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/blobs/6302/8111536/6d97fd5b0b0e/10.1177_20420986211012592-fig1.jpg

相似文献

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索