Department of Ethics, Law and Humanities, 1209Amsterdam UMC, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Department of Philosophy, 404761Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
J Empir Res Hum Res Ethics. 2021 Oct;16(4):450-460. doi: 10.1177/15562646211018916. Epub 2021 May 26.
This opinion piece aims to inform future research funding programs on responsible research practices (RRP) based on three specific objectives: (1) to give a sketch of the current international discussion on responsible research practices (RRPs); (2) to give an overview of current initiatives and already obtained results regarding RRP; and (3) to give an overview of potential future needs for research on RRP. In this opinion piece, we have used seven iterative methodological steps (including literature review, ranking, and sorting exercises) to create the proposed research agenda. We identified six main themes that we believe need attention in future research: (1) responsible evaluation of research and researchers, (2) the influence of open science and transparency on RRP, (3) research on responsible mentoring, supervision, and role modeling, (4) the effect of education and training on RRP, (5) checking for reproducibility, and (6) responsible and fair peer review. These themes have in common that they address aspects of research that are mostly on the level of the scientific system, more than on the level of the individual researcher. Some current initiatives are already gathering substantial empirical evidence to start filling these gaps. We believe that with sufficient support from all relevant stakeholders, more progress can be made.
这篇观点文章旨在基于三个具体目标,为负责任的研究实践(RRP)的未来研究资助计划提供信息:(1)概述当前关于负责任的研究实践(RRP)的国际讨论;(2)概述 RRP 的当前举措和已经取得的成果;(3)概述 RRP 研究的潜在未来需求。在这篇观点文章中,我们使用了七个迭代的方法步骤(包括文献综述、排名和分类练习)来创建拟议的研究议程。我们确定了六个主要主题,我们认为这些主题需要在未来的研究中得到关注:(1)负责任的研究和研究人员评估;(2)开放科学和透明度对 RRP 的影响;(3)负责任的指导、监督和角色建模的研究;(4)教育和培训对 RRP 的影响;(5)检查可重复性;(6)负责任和公平的同行评审。这些主题的共同点是,它们都涉及到研究的各个方面,这些方面主要是在科学系统层面上,而不是在单个研究人员层面上。一些当前的举措已经在收集大量的经验证据,以开始填补这些空白。我们相信,在所有相关利益相关者的充分支持下,可以取得更多的进展。