Archer R P, Gordon R A
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Eastern Virginia Medical School, Norfolk 23501.
J Pers Assess. 1988 Summer;52(2):276-87. doi: 10.1207/s15327752jpa5202_9.
Although adolescent norms have been developed for the MMPI (e.g., Marks, Seeman, & Haller, 1974) and Rorschach (e.g., Exner, 1986a), little is known regarding the discriminate diagnostic validity of these measures with adolescents. This study investigated the usefulness of these measures in the detection of depression and schizophrenia among adolescent inpatients. Subjects (mean age = 15.3) consisted of 134 adolescents who received Rorschach and MMPI administrations at hospital admission. Clinical diagnoses resulted in the following groupings for this sample: schizophrenia = 15, dysthymic disorder = 41, major depression = 26, conduct disorder = 28, personality disorder = 18. MMPI scale Sc elevation was found to be the most effective single predictor of schizophrenic diagnoses, with a hit rate of .76, sensitivity of .62, and specificity of .78. Neither MMPI scale D scores nor Rorschach DEPI scores were found to be significantly related to patients' diagnoses. Results were interpreted in terms of prior findings in adult psychiatric populations and in relation to implications for the clinical assessment of adolescents.
尽管已经为明尼苏达多相人格测验(如Marks、Seeman和Haller,1974年)以及罗夏墨迹测验(如Exner,1986a)制定了青少年常模,但对于这些测量方法在青少年中的鉴别诊断效度却知之甚少。本研究调查了这些测量方法在检测青少年住院患者抑郁和精神分裂症方面的有用性。研究对象(平均年龄=15.3岁)包括134名青少年,他们在入院时接受了罗夏墨迹测验和明尼苏达多相人格测验。临床诊断将该样本分为以下几组:精神分裂症=15例,恶劣心境障碍=41例,重度抑郁症=26例,品行障碍=28例,人格障碍=18例。发现明尼苏达多相人格测验的Sc量表升高是精神分裂症诊断最有效的单一预测指标,命中率为0.76,敏感性为0.62,特异性为0.78。未发现明尼苏达多相人格测验的D量表分数和罗夏墨迹测验的DEPI分数与患者诊断有显著相关性。研究结果根据成人精神病患者群体的先前研究结果进行了解释,并探讨了其对青少年临床评估的意义。