Department of Statistics, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
Snow Leopard Trust, Seattle, Washington.
Biometrics. 2022 Sep;78(3):963-973. doi: 10.1111/biom.13502. Epub 2021 Jun 8.
Spatial capture-recapture (SCR) models are commonly used to estimate animal density from surveys on which detectors passively detect animals without physical capture, for example, using camera traps, hair snares, or microphones. An individual is more likely to be recorded by detectors close to its activity center, the centroid of its movement throughout the survey. Existing models to account for this spatial heterogeneity in detection probabilities rely on an assumption of independence between detection records at different detectors conditional on the animals' activity centers, which are treated as latent variables. In this paper, we show that this conditional independence assumption may be violated due to the way animals move around the survey region and encounter detectors, such that additional spatial correlation is almost inevitable. We highlight the links between the well-studied issue of unmodeled temporal heterogeneity in nonspatial capture-recapture and this variety of unmodeled spatial heterogeneity in SCR, showing that the latter causes predictable bias in the same way as the former. We address this by introducing a latent detection field into the model, and illustrate the resulting approach with a simulation study and an application to a camera-trap survey of snow leopards Panthera uncia. Our method is a unifying model for several existing SCR approaches, with special cases including standard SCR, models that account for nonspatial individual heterogeneity, and models with overdispersed detection counts.
空间捕捉-再捕获(SCR)模型通常用于根据探测器被动地检测动物而无需物理捕获的调查来估计动物密度,例如使用相机陷阱、毛发陷阱或麦克风。个体更有可能被靠近其活动中心(即在整个调查期间其运动的质心)的探测器记录下来。现有的考虑检测概率中这种空间异质性的模型依赖于一个假设,即不同探测器上的检测记录在条件下是独立的动物的活动中心,这些活动中心被视为潜在变量。在本文中,我们表明,由于动物在调查区域内移动并遇到探测器的方式,这种条件独立性假设可能会被违反,因此几乎不可避免地会产生额外的空间相关性。我们强调了在非空间捕捉-再捕获中研究得很好的未建模时间异质性问题与 SCR 中这种未建模空间异质性之间的联系,表明后者以与前者相同的方式引起可预测的偏差。我们通过在模型中引入潜在检测场来解决这个问题,并通过模拟研究和对雪豹 Panthera uncia 的相机陷阱调查的应用来说明这种方法。我们的方法是几种现有 SCR 方法的统一模型,其特例包括标准 SCR、考虑非空间个体异质性的模型以及具有过度离散检测计数的模型。