Kane M J
School of Health, Physical Education and Recreation, Bowling Green State University, Ohio 43403.
Adolescence. 1988 Summer;23(90):253-64.
This study examined the relationship between female athletic participation and status attainment within the social status systems of high school adolescents. Although earlier research has consistently demonstrated that the athletic role for males is associated with greatest status within the school, findings regarding the status of female athletes have been contradictory: Some studies have found high status rankings for female athletes while others have revealed negative results. It was therefore argued that current research go beyond the general construct of "female athlete" and consider the type of sport with which the adolescent female is associated as a possible status determinant. Employing a sport typology proposed by Metheny (1967), it was predicted that females associated with sex-appropriate or "feminine" sports (e.g., tennis) would receive significantly higher status ratings than those identified with sex-inappropriate or "masculine" sports (e.g., basketball). One hundred and twenty-one male subjects were asked to indicate which female athlete (associated with a sex-appropriate versus a sex-inappropriate sport) they would most like to date, while 111 female subjects were asked to choose which female athlete they would most like to have as a friend. Chi-square analyses revealed that, as predicted, females associated with sex-appropriate sports were given significantly greater status than females identified with sex-inappropriate sports by both male and female subjects. These results suggest that social assessments made about female sport participation within high school status systems remain heavily influenced by traditional beliefs regarding feminine, "ladylike" behavior.
本研究考察了高中青少年社会地位体系中女性参与体育运动与地位获得之间的关系。尽管早期研究一直表明,男性的运动角色与学校内的最高地位相关,但关于女性运动员地位的研究结果却相互矛盾:一些研究发现女性运动员地位排名较高,而另一些研究则得出了负面结果。因此,有人认为当前的研究应超越“女运动员”这一笼统概念,将青少年女性参与的运动类型视为可能的地位决定因素。采用梅思尼(1967年)提出的运动类型学,研究预测,参与适合女性或“女性化”运动(如网球)的女性,其地位评级将显著高于参与不适合女性或“男性化”运动(如篮球)的女性。121名男性受试者被要求指出他们最想与之约会的女运动员(参与适合女性运动的与参与不适合女性运动的),111名女性受试者被要求选择她们最想与之成为朋友的女运动员。卡方分析表明,正如预测的那样,无论是男性还是女性受试者,参与适合女性运动的女性所获得的地位都显著高于参与不适合女性运动的女性。这些结果表明,在高中地位体系中,对女性参与体育运动的社会评价仍然深受关于女性化、“淑女”行为的传统观念的影响。