Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA.
Institute for Social Research, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2021 Jul;45(7):1458-1467. doi: 10.1111/acer.14629. Epub 2021 Jun 5.
Understanding the nature of the association between cannabis and alcohol use within individuals over time in the era of legalized cannabis is of crucial importance for assessing the public health consequences of increasing cannabis use. An important unanswered question is whether cannabis and alcohol use substitute for one another. Specifically, is greater use of one substance associated with less use of the other substance (i.e., a negative association) or are the substances complementary and their association positive?
We used 24 consecutive months of data on a young adult sample (n = 774; 56% female, age 18-25 during the study) who drank alcohol in the year prior to enrollment. The sample was recruited in Washington State in 2015/2016 (after legalization of nonmedical cannabis) using media advertisements and community flyers and outreach. Using parallel process latent growth curve models, we assessed three types of association between cannabis and alcohol use across the 24-month period: (1) an association between average levels of cannabis and alcohol use; (2) an association between rates of change in cannabis and alcohol use; and (3) correlations between shorter-term deviations/fluctuations off of longer-term trajectories of level and change in cannabis and alcohol use.
We found a positive association between the average frequency of cannabis and alcohol use; individuals who used cannabis more frequently on average also drank alcohol more frequently on average. Change over time in cannabis use was positively associated with change in alcohol use. There was also a contemporaneous positive association between fluctuations in cannabis and alcohol use.
Overall, we found no evidence of substitution. Rather, the results suggest a complementary relationship between cannabis and alcohol use, such that the use of cannabis and alcohol rises and falls together.
在大麻合法化时代,了解个体在一段时间内大麻和酒精使用之间的关联性质对于评估不断增加的大麻使用对公共健康的影响至关重要。一个尚未解决的重要问题是,大麻和酒精的使用是否相互替代。具体来说,一种物质的使用量增加是否与另一种物质的使用量减少相关(即负相关),或者这两种物质是否互补且相关为正?
我们使用了 774 名年轻成年人样本在过去一年中饮酒的数据(n=774;56%为女性,研究期间年龄为 18-25 岁),这些数据来自于 2015/2016 年在华盛顿州进行的一项研究(在非医用大麻合法化之后),通过媒体广告和社区传单以及外展活动招募了这些样本。使用平行过程潜增长曲线模型,我们评估了大麻和酒精使用在 24 个月期间的三种关联类型:(1)大麻和酒精使用平均水平之间的关联;(2)大麻和酒精使用变化率之间的关联;以及(3)大麻和酒精使用的短期偏离/波动与长期水平和变化轨迹之间的相关性。
我们发现大麻和酒精使用的平均频率之间存在正相关;平均使用大麻频率较高的个体也会平均饮酒频率较高。大麻使用的时间变化与酒精使用的变化呈正相关。大麻和酒精使用的波动之间也存在同时的正相关。
总体而言,我们没有发现替代的证据。相反,结果表明大麻和酒精使用之间存在互补关系,即大麻和酒精的使用一起上升和下降。