Temple University, Department of Psychology, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Temple University, Department of Psychology, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Clin Psychol Rev. 2021 Aug;88:102050. doi: 10.1016/j.cpr.2021.102050. Epub 2021 Jun 10.
Repetitive negative thinking (RNT) and executive functioning (EF) deficits are each characteristic of many forms of youth psychopathology. Extensive work has examined the relationship between rumination, a form of RNT, and EF in adults. However, less is known about the relationship between RNT more broadly and EF in youth, for whom these constructs are developing and emerging. Here, we systematically and qualitatively reviewed 27 studies on the associations between EF (e.g., shifting, inhibition, working memory) and RNT (e.g., rumination, worry, obsessions) in youth. All forms of RNT were more commonly positively associated with questionnaire-reported EF problems in daily life, most frequently in the domain of shifting. Task-based assessments of EF were less consistently associated with RNT in youth, with no strong pattern of presence vs. absence of associations. Further, limited longitudinal work has been conducted on this topic to date. This review integrates initial work with regard to RNT and EF deficits in a still-developing population, and discusses clear future need for longitudinal, multi-method assessments of the relationship between RNT and EF subtypes in youth.
重复性消极思维(RNT)和执行功能(EF)缺陷是许多形式的青年精神病理学的特征。大量研究已经检查了成年人中反刍思维(RNT 的一种形式)和 EF 之间的关系。然而,对于这些结构正在发展和出现的年轻人来说,关于 RNT 更广泛与 EF 之间的关系的了解较少。在这里,我们系统地和定性地回顾了 27 项关于 EF(例如转换、抑制、工作记忆)与 RNT(例如反刍、担忧、痴迷)在年轻人中的关联的研究。所有形式的 RNT 与日常生活中问卷报告的 EF 问题更常呈正相关,在转换领域最常见。在年轻人中,基于任务的 EF 评估与 RNT 的相关性不太一致,没有存在与不存在关联的明显模式。此外,迄今为止,关于这个主题的纵向研究工作非常有限。本综述整合了关于 RNT 和 EF 缺陷在仍在发展中的人群中的初步工作,并讨论了需要对年轻人的 RNT 和 EF 亚型之间的关系进行长期、多方法评估的明确未来需求。