Baumer J H, Wadsworth J, Taylor B
Department of Child Health, Freedom Fields Hospital, Plymouth.
Arch Dis Child. 1988 Aug;63(8):942-7. doi: 10.1136/adc.63.8.942.
Children from a national birth cohort living in families in which a sibling had died or been stillborn were compared with children living in similarly structured families where no such tragedy had occurred by a number of health, developmental, and behavioural outcomes. Surprisingly little ill effect from a sibling death (occurring either before or after the birth of study children) was apparent at the age of 5 years. Families experiencing a stillbirth or death of a child were socially disadvantaged. Even allowing for this and other likely intervening factors, however, a child whose adjacent sibling had died was significantly more liable to bronchitis or wheezing during the first 5 years. Mothers who had experienced the death of a child since the study child's birth had high scores on a psychological screening test, and were more likely to be single parents. Mothers who had lost a child were more likely to smoke during the next pregnancy. No significant differences between cases and control subjects were detected on other health, behavioural, or developmental outcomes. Stillbirth or death of a child appears to have little measurable effect on siblings assessed at 5 years of age. This study does not exclude important longer term psychological effects from sibling death.
对来自全国出生队列、其家庭中有兄弟姐妹死亡或死产的儿童,与生活在结构相似但未发生此类悲剧家庭中的儿童,就一些健康、发育和行为结果进行了比较。令人惊讶的是,在5岁时,兄弟姐妹死亡(发生在研究对象儿童出生之前或之后)几乎没有明显的不良影响。经历过死产或孩子死亡的家庭在社会上处于不利地位。然而,即便考虑到这一点及其他可能的干预因素,相邻兄弟姐妹死亡的儿童在头5年患支气管炎或喘息的可能性仍显著更高。自研究对象儿童出生后经历过孩子死亡的母亲在心理筛查测试中得分较高,且更有可能是单亲妈妈。失去孩子的母亲在下一次怀孕时更有可能吸烟。在其他健康、行为或发育结果方面,未发现病例组和对照组之间存在显著差异。孩子的死产或死亡似乎对5岁时接受评估的兄弟姐妹几乎没有可衡量的影响。本研究并未排除兄弟姐妹死亡产生的重要长期心理影响。