Shin Kyusoo
Center for Employment Impact Assessment, Korea Labor Institution, 603, C Bldg., Sejong National Research Complex, 370, Sicheong-daero, Sejong-si, 30147, Republic of Korea.
Saf Health Work. 2021 Jun;12(2):261-267. doi: 10.1016/j.shaw.2020.12.006. Epub 2020 Dec 17.
The series of serious industrial accidents in recent years at contractors to large companies has highlighted risk outsourcing as a real and urgent problem. This study aims to review the difference in the degree of risk exposure and the occurrence of industrial accidents depending on the type of company relations. Among in-house contractors, the focus will be on those handling hazardous chemicals that include companies for which outsourcing requires approval.
This study uses the 9th wave of the Industrial Safety and Health Survey (2018). For determining the degree of risk exposure, the occurrence of industrial accidents, and industrial accident rate, multivariate, logistic, and fractional logit, regression analyses were used, respectively.
First, In-house contractors' degree of risk exposure is higher than that of the client companies. In particular, this gap is even greater for companies dealing with chemicals. Second, among only those that handle hazardous chemicals, in-house contractors do show a significantly higher rate of industrial accident occurrence. Third, In-house contractors have a significantly higher rate of industrial accidents from diseases than client companies.
The analysis supports the intent of the legal amendment that strengthens the protection of in-house contracted workers who handle hazardous chemicals. Second, the results of this study suggest that safety and health management must go beyond legal compliance and ensure that it has substance and effectiveness. Last, there should be policy consideration is necessary to reduce attempts to hide industrial accidents.
近年来,大公司承包商发生的一系列严重工业事故凸显了风险外包这一现实且紧迫的问题。本研究旨在探讨根据公司关系类型,风险暴露程度和工业事故发生率的差异。在内部承包商中,重点将放在那些处理危险化学品的承包商上,其中包括外包需要审批的公司。
本研究使用了第九次工业安全与健康调查(2018年)的数据。为了确定风险暴露程度、工业事故发生率和工业事故率,分别使用了多元回归分析、逻辑回归分析和分数对数回归分析。
首先,内部承包商的风险暴露程度高于客户公司。特别是,对于从事化学品业务的公司来说,这种差距更大。其次,在仅处理危险化学品的公司中,内部承包商的工业事故发生率确实显著更高。第三,内部承包商因疾病导致的工业事故发生率显著高于客户公司。
该分析支持了加强对处理危险化学品的内部合同制工人保护的法律修正案的意图。其次,本研究结果表明,安全与健康管理必须超越法律合规性,确保其具有实质性和有效性。最后,有必要进行政策考量,以减少隐瞒工业事故的企图。