Letlotlo Bokang L, Lumu Lavinia D, Moosa Mahomed Y H, Jeenah Fatima Y
Department of Psychiatry, Faculty of Neurosciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
S Afr J Psychiatr. 2021 May 28;27:1614. doi: 10.4102/sajpsychiatry.v27i0.1614. eCollection 2021.
Neuro-imaging is relatively new in psychiatry. Although the actual role of neuro-imaging in psychiatry remains unclear, it is used to strengthen clinical evidence in making psychiatric diagnoses.
To analyse the records of inpatients referred for neuro-imaging (computerised tomography [CT] and/or magnetic resonance imaging [MRI] scans) to determine the proportion of abnormal neuro-imaging results and, if any, factors associated with abnormal neuro-imaging results.
This study was conducted at the Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital (CMJAH) situated in Johannesburg, South Africa.
This was a quantitative retrospective record review. All adult psychiatric inpatients who had undergone a CT and/or MRI scan during 01 January 2014 to 31 December 2015 were included. Out-patients or patients admitted in the medical wards were excluded from the study. All neuro-imaging referrals were identified from hospital records and their demographics, scan characteristics and diagnoses were subsequently captured.
A total of 1040 patients were admitted to the CMJAH psychiatric unit, of which 213 (20.5%) underwent neuro-imaging tests. Of the 213 scans performed, 74 were abnormal, representing a yield of 34.7%. The most common reported pathology was atrophy ( = 22, 29.7%). There was no statistically significant association between age group ( = 3.9, = 0.8), gender ( = 1.3; = 0.5), psychiatric diagnoses and abnormal scans. However, there were trends towards an association with comorbid HIV infection ( = 3.476, = 0.062) and comorbid substance abuse ( = 2.286, = 0.091).
This study supports the need for clear clinical indications to justify the cost-effective use of neuro-imaging in psychiatry. This study's high yield of abnormal CT scans, although similar to other studies, advocates that HIV positive testing and the presence of focal neurological signs will improve the yield further.
神经影像学在精神病学领域相对较新。尽管神经影像学在精神病学中的实际作用仍不明确,但它被用于加强精神病诊断中的临床证据。
分析因神经影像学检查(计算机断层扫描[CT]和/或磁共振成像[MRI]扫描)而转诊的住院患者记录,以确定神经影像学检查结果异常的比例,以及与神经影像学检查结果异常相关的因素(如有)。
本研究在位于南非约翰内斯堡的夏洛特·马克西克约翰内斯堡学术医院(CMJAH)进行。
这是一项定量回顾性记录审查。纳入了2014年1月1日至2015年12月31日期间接受过CT和/或MRI扫描的所有成年精神科住院患者。门诊患者或在内科病房住院的患者被排除在研究之外。所有神经影像学转诊均从医院记录中识别出来,随后记录其人口统计学信息、扫描特征和诊断结果。
共有1040名患者入住CMJAH精神科病房,其中213名(20.5%)接受了神经影像学检查。在进行的213次扫描中,74次异常,阳性率为34.7%。报告的最常见病理是萎缩(n = 22,29.7%)。年龄组(χ² = 3.9,p = 0.8)、性别(χ² = 1.3;p = 0.5)、精神科诊断与异常扫描之间无统计学显著关联。然而,存在与合并HIV感染(χ² = 3.476,p = 0.062)和合并物质滥用(χ² = 2.286,p = 0.091)相关的趋势。
本研究支持需要明确的临床指征,以证明在精神病学中经济有效地使用神经影像学检查的合理性。本研究中CT扫描异常的高阳性率,尽管与其他研究相似,但表明HIV阳性检测和局灶性神经体征的存在将进一步提高阳性率。