Temsah Mohamad-Hani, Abouammoh Noura, Ashry Ahmed, Al-Eyadhy Ayman, Alhaboob Ali, Alsohime Fahad, Almazyad Mohammed, Alabdulhafid Majed, Temsah Reem, Aljamaan Fadi, Jamal Amr, Halwani Rabih, Alhasan Khalid, Al-Tawfiq Jaffar A, Barry Mazin
College of Medicine, King Saud University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
Pediatric Intensive Care Unit, Department of Pediatrics, King Saud University Medical City, King Saud University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
J Multidiscip Healthc. 2021 Jun 25;14:1571-1581. doi: 10.2147/JMDH.S310028. eCollection 2021.
A key measure to mitigate coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has been social distancing. Incorporating video-conferencing applications in the patient handover process between healthcare workers can enhance social distancing while maintaining handover elements. This study describes pediatric intensive care unit (PICU) physicians' experience using an online video-conferencing application for handover during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Qualitative content analysis.
PICU at a university hospital in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
PICU Physicians.
Due to the pandemic, the hospital's PICU used Zoom as a remote conferencing application instead of a face-to-face handover. Following institutional review board approval, data were collected over two weeks (1 Jul 2020 to 14 Jul 2020).
An online survey was conducted using open-ended questions to capture demographic data and the perceived efficacy of remote handovers. Thematic framework analysis process included open coding, creating categories, and abstraction.
All 37 PICU physicians who participated in the handover completed the survey. The participants comprised six attendings, nine specialists, and 22 residents. While 20 (54.1%) physicians reported attending 1-5 Zoom handovers by the time of the study, some (n. 6, 16.2%) had more than ten virtual handovers. They had variable previous teleconferencing experiences. Most physicians (78.4%) were comfortable conducting a remote handover. Most found that Situation-Background-Assessment-Recommendation handover elements were properly achieved through this remote handover process. The perceived advantages of online handover included fewer interruptions, time efficiency, and facilitation of social distancing. The perceived disadvantages were the paucity of nonverbal communication and teaching during virtual meetings.
Video-conferencing applications for online handovers could supplement traditional face-to-face intensive care unit patient handover during outbreaks of infectious diseases. The use of video streaming and more emphasis on teaching should be encouraged to optimize the users' experience.
减轻2019冠状病毒病(COVID-19)的一项关键措施是保持社交距离。在医护人员之间的患者交接过程中纳入视频会议应用程序,可以在保持交接要素的同时加强社交距离。本研究描述了儿科重症监护病房(PICU)医生在COVID-19大流行期间使用在线视频会议应用程序进行交接的经验。
定性内容分析。
沙特阿拉伯利雅得一家大学医院的PICU。
PICU医生。
由于疫情,该医院的PICU使用Zoom作为远程会议应用程序,而非面对面交接。经机构审查委员会批准,在两周内(2020年7月1日至2020年7月14日)收集数据。
使用开放式问题进行在线调查,以获取人口统计学数据以及对远程交接的感知效果。主题框架分析过程包括开放编码、创建类别和抽象。
所有37名参与交接的PICU医生完成了调查。参与者包括6名主治医师、9名专科医生和22名住院医师。在研究时,20名(54.1%)医生报告参加了1至5次Zoom交接,一些医生(6名,16.2%)参加了十多次虚拟交接。他们以前的电话会议经验各不相同。大多数医生(78.4%)对进行远程交接感到满意。大多数人发现,通过这种远程交接过程能够恰当地实现情况-背景-评估-建议交接要素。在线交接的感知优势包括干扰较少、时间效率高以及便于保持社交距离。感知到的劣势是虚拟会议期间非语言交流和教学不足。
在线交接的视频会议应用程序可以在传染病暴发期间补充传统的面对面重症监护病房患者交接。应鼓励使用视频流并更加强调教学,以优化用户体验。