Bandyopadhyay Anis, Ghosh Arnab Kumar, Chhatui Bappaditya, Das Dhiman
Department of Radiotherapy, Medical College Kolkata, Kolkata, India.
Rep Pract Oncol Radiother. 2021 Apr 14;26(2):170-178. doi: 10.5603/RPOR.a2021.0023. eCollection 2021.
Brachytherapy for carcinoma cervix has moved from Point A based planning to optimization of dose based on HR-CTV. Guidelines have been published by GEC ESTRO on HR-CTV delineation based on clinical gynecological examination and MR sequences. These have given significant clinical results in terms of local control. However, many centers around the country and worldwide still use CT based planning, which restricts HR-CTV delineation, as disease and cervix can rarely be differentiated on a planning CT. Various studies have been done to develop CT based contouring guidelines from the available data, but enough evidence is not available on the clinical outcome when treatment is optimized to HR-CTV contoured on CT images. The purpose of this study is to find out the relation between local control and dosimetry of HR-CTV as delineated on CT images.
Patients of locally advanced carcinoma cervix treated radically with EBRT of 50 Gy in 25# and at least 4 cycles of concurrent weekly Cisplatin having a complete or partial response to EBRT were taken for study. All patients had completed CT based Intracavitary brachytherapy to 21 Gy in 3# of 7 Gy per # with dose prescription at point A and optimizing dose to reduce bladder and rectal toxicity. Follow up data on locoregional recurrence was obtained. HR-CTV delineation was done retrospectively on the treatment plan following guidelines by Viswanathan et al. EQD2 doses for EBRT+BT were calculated for point A and HR-CTV D90. The dosimetric data to HR-CTV and to Point A were then compared with patients with locoregional control and with local recurrence.
48 patients were taken, all had squamous cell carcinoma. The median age was 48 years. 33.33% were stage IIA, the rest were stage IIB. Median follow-up was 30 months with 25% developing recurrence of the disease. HR-CTV D90 EQD2 dose was significantly higher in patients with locoregionally controlled disease than in patients with local recurrence (83.97 Gy 77.96 Gy, p = 0.002). Patients with HR-CTV D90 EQD2 dose greater than or equal to 79.75 Gy 10 had better locoregional control than patients receiving dose less than 79.75 Gy (p = 0.015). Kaplan Meier plot for PFS showed significantly improved PFS for patients receiving HR-CTV D90 dose of at least 79.75 Gy (log-rank p-value = 0.007). Three year progression free survival was 87.1% in patients receiving HR-CTV D90 dose of at least 79.75 Gy.
CT based HR-CTV volume delineation with the help of pre brachytherapy clinical diagrams and MRI imaging may be feasible in a select subgroup of patients with complete or near-complete response to external beam radiation.
子宫颈癌近距离放射治疗已从基于A点的计划发展到基于高危临床靶区(HR-CTV)的剂量优化。妇科肿瘤和放射肿瘤学组(GEC ESTRO)已发布基于临床妇科检查和磁共振序列进行HR-CTV勾画的指南。这些指南在局部控制方面取得了显著的临床效果。然而,国内和世界各地的许多中心仍在使用基于CT的计划,这限制了HR-CTV的勾画,因为在计划CT上疾病和子宫颈很少能区分开来。已经进行了各种研究以根据现有数据制定基于CT的轮廓勾画指南,但当治疗优化到在CT图像上勾画的HR-CTV时,关于临床结果的证据还不足。本研究的目的是找出在CT图像上勾画的HR-CTV的局部控制与剂量学之间的关系。
选取局部晚期子宫颈癌患者,接受25次分割共50 Gy的外照射放疗(EBRT),并至少接受4个周期每周同步顺铂治疗,且对EBRT有完全或部分反应的患者进行研究。所有患者均完成了基于CT的腔内近距离放射治疗,剂量为3次分割共21 Gy,每次分割7 Gy,剂量处方点为A点,并优化剂量以降低膀胱和直肠毒性。获得了局部区域复发的随访数据。根据维斯瓦纳坦等人的指南对治疗计划进行回顾性HR-CTV勾画。计算A点和HR-CTV D90的EBRT+近距离放疗(BT)的等效均匀剂量(EQD2)。然后将HR-CTV和A点的剂量学数据与局部区域控制和局部复发的患者进行比较。
共纳入48例患者,均为鳞状细胞癌。中位年龄为48岁。33.33%为IIA期,其余为IIB期。中位随访时间为30个月,25%的患者出现疾病复发。局部区域控制的患者HR-CTV D90 EQD2剂量显著高于局部复发的患者(83.97 Gy对77.96 Gy,p = 0.002)。HR-CTV D90 EQD2剂量大于或等于79.75 Gy的患者比接受剂量小于79.75 Gy的患者有更好的局部区域控制(p = 0.015)。无进展生存期(PFS)的Kaplan-Meier曲线显示,接受HR-CTV D90剂量至少79.75 Gy的患者PFS显著改善(对数秩p值 = 0.007)。接受HR-CTV D90剂量至少79.75 Gy的患者三年无进展生存率为87.1%。
对于对外照射放疗有完全或接近完全反应的特定亚组患者,借助近距离放疗前临床图表和磁共振成像进行基于CT的HR-CTV体积勾画可能是可行的。