Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, The First People's Hospital of Changzhou &Third Affiliated Hospital of Soochow University, Changzhou, China.
Appl Neuropsychol Adult. 2023 Jul-Aug;30(4):414-418. doi: 10.1080/23279095.2021.1952588. Epub 2021 Jul 15.
The purpose of this study was to investigate the influence of education level on MMSE and MoCA scores of elderly inpatients.
This is a cross-sectional study. A total of 260 elderly inpatients were evaluated by the MMSE and MoCA sequentially.
The total MMSE scores were highly correlated with the total MoCA scores ( = 0.7629, < 0.0001), and were correlated with the length of education ( = 0.2723, < 0.0001). The total MoCA scores were also correlated with the length of education ( = 0.3323, < 0.0001). Meanwhile, MoCA was also used to reevaluate the elderly inpatients with normal MMSE scores at different education levels. There were no significant differences at different education levels (=1.351, = 0.5090). Finally, we analyzed the diagnostic consistency of MMSE and MoCA at different education levels, and the results showed that education level was closely related to the consistency of the diagnoses based on the MMSE and MoCA (=10.23, = 0.0368).
In general, the results of both the MMSE and MoCA were influenced by education level, and this effect was more obvious for the MoCA. However, in the cognitive assessment of elderly patients, the ability to identify impairment with the MoCA is obviously superior to that with the MMSE.
本研究旨在探讨教育水平对老年住院患者 MMSE 和 MoCA 评分的影响。
这是一项横断面研究。共对 260 例老年住院患者进行 MMSE 和 MoCA 评估。
MMSE 总分与 MoCA 总分高度相关(r=0.7629,P<0.0001),与受教育年限相关(r=0.2723,P<0.0001)。MoCA 总分也与受教育年限相关(r=0.3323,P<0.0001)。同时,MoCA 还用于重新评估不同受教育程度 MMSE 评分正常的老年住院患者,不同受教育程度间无显著差异(Z=1.351,P=0.5090)。最后,我们分析了不同受教育程度 MMSE 和 MoCA 的诊断一致性,结果表明教育水平与基于 MMSE 和 MoCA 的诊断一致性密切相关(Z=10.23,P=0.0368)。
一般来说,MMSE 和 MoCA 的结果都受教育水平的影响,而 MoCA 的影响更为明显。然而,在老年患者的认知评估中,MoCA 识别损害的能力明显优于 MMSE。