From the Center for Vulnerable Populations, University of California, San Francisco (KHN, JDF, AGC, RD, AA, WB, US, CRL); UCSF Department of Medicine, Division of General Internal Medicine at Zuckerberg, San Francisco General Hospital, CA (KHN, JDF, AGC, US, CRL); Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, University of California, San Francisco (KHN, JDF, RD, US, CRL); Kaiser Permanente Northern California, Division of Research, Oakland (AG, CRL); Streetwyze, Oakland, CA (TC, AS, AA); Social Innovation and Universal Opportunity Lab (SOUL), University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco State University (TC, AS, AA); Center for AIDS Prevention Studies, University of California, San Francisco (WB); Bakar Computational Health Science Institute, University of California, San Francisco (WB, CRL).
J Am Board Fam Med. 2021 Jul-Aug;34(4):698-708. doi: 10.3122/jabfm.2021.04.200591.
Social determinants of health (SDoH) influence health outcomes and contribute to disparities in chronic disease in vulnerable populations. To inform health system strategies to address SDoH, we conducted a multi-stakeholder qualitative study to capture the multi-level influences on health for those living in socio-economically deprived contexts.
Varied qualitative inquiry methods - in-depth interviews, participant-led neighborhood tours, and clinic visit observations - involving a total of 23 participants (10 patients with chronic illnesses in San Francisco neighborhoods with high chronic disease rates, 10 community leaders serving the same neighborhoods, and 3 providers from San Francisco's public health care delivery system). Qualitative analyses were guided by the Chronic Care Model (CCM).
Several key themes emerged from this study. First, we enumerated a large array, neighborhood resources such as food pantries, parks/green spaces, and financial assistance services that interact with patients' self-management. Health service providers leveraged these resources to address patients' social needs but suggested a clear need for expanding this work. Second, analyses uncovered multiple essential mechanisms by which community-based organizations (CBOs) provided and navigated among many neighborhood health resources, including social support and culturally aligned knowledge. Finally, many examples of how structural issues such as institutional racism, transportation, and housing inequities are intertwined with health and social service delivery were elucidated.
The results contribute new evidence toward the community domain of the CCM. Health care systems must intentionally partner with CBOs to address SDoH and improve community resources for chronic care management, and directly address structural issues to make progress.
健康的社会决定因素(SDoH)会影响健康结果,并导致弱势人群的慢性疾病存在差异。为了为解决 SDoH 的卫生系统战略提供信息,我们进行了一项多利益相关者的定性研究,以了解生活在社会经济贫困环境中的人们的多层次健康影响。
采用多种定性研究方法——深入访谈、参与者主导的社区参观和诊所观察,共涉及 23 名参与者(10 名患有慢性疾病的患者,居住在旧金山高慢性疾病率的社区;10 名服务于同一社区的社区领袖;以及 3 名来自旧金山公共医疗服务系统的提供者)。定性分析以慢性护理模型(CCM)为指导。
从这项研究中出现了几个关键主题。首先,我们列举了大量的社区资源,例如食品储藏室、公园/绿地和经济援助服务,这些资源与患者的自我管理相互作用。卫生服务提供者利用这些资源来解决患者的社会需求,但也建议明确需要扩大这项工作。其次,分析揭示了社区组织(CBO)提供和管理许多社区健康资源的多个基本机制,包括社会支持和文化契合的知识。最后,阐明了许多结构性问题(例如制度种族主义、交通和住房不平等)与健康和社会服务提供交织在一起的例子。
研究结果为 CCM 的社区领域提供了新的证据。医疗保健系统必须有意与 CBO 合作,以解决 SDoH 问题,并改善慢性病管理的社区资源,并直接解决结构性问题以取得进展。