Department of Computer Engineering, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
Department of Optometry, Tehran Medical University, Tehran, Iran.
Int Ophthalmol. 2021 Dec;41(12):3935-3948. doi: 10.1007/s10792-021-01963-2. Epub 2021 Jul 28.
The present study was done to evaluate efficiency of an ensemble learning structure for automatic keratoconus diagnosis and to categorize eyes into four different groups based on a combination of 19 parameters obtained from Pentacam measurements.
Pentacam data from 450 eyes were enrolled in the study. Eyes were separated into training, validation, and testing sets. An ensemble system was used to analyze corneal measurements and categorize the eyes into four groups. The ensemble system was trained to consider indices from both anterior and posterior corneal surfaces. Efficiency of the ensemble system was evaluated and compared in each group.
The best accuracy was achieved by the ensemble system with both multilayer perceptron and neuro-fuzzy system classifiers alongside the Naïve Bayes combination method. The accuracy achieved in KC versus N distinction task was equal to 98.2% with 99.1% of sensitivity and 96.2% of specificity for KC detection. The global accuracy was equal to 98.2% for classification of 4 groups, with an average sensitivity of 98.5% and specificity of 99.4%.
In this study, authority of an ensemble learning system to work out intricate problems was presented. Despite using fewer parameters, herein, comparable or, in some cases, better results were obtained than methods reported in the literature. The proposed method demonstrated very good accuracy in discriminating between normal eyes and different stages of keratoconus eyes. In some cases, it was not possible to directly compare our results with the literature, due to differences in definitions of KC group as well as differences in selection of items and parameters.
本研究旨在评估集成学习结构在自动圆锥角膜诊断中的效率,并根据 Pentacam 测量得到的 19 个参数组合将眼睛分为四个不同组别。
本研究纳入了 450 只眼睛的 Pentacam 数据。将眼睛分为训练集、验证集和测试集。使用集成系统分析角膜测量值,并将眼睛分为四个组别。该集成系统经过训练可考虑前、后角膜表面的指数。在每组中评估并比较集成系统的效率。
具有多层感知机和神经模糊系统分类器以及朴素贝叶斯组合方法的集成系统取得了最佳的准确性。在 KC 与 N 区分任务中的准确率达到 98.2%,敏感性为 99.1%,特异性为 96.2%。对于 4 组的分类,整体准确率为 98.2%,平均敏感性为 98.5%,特异性为 99.4%。
本研究展示了集成学习系统解决复杂问题的能力。尽管使用的参数较少,但与文献中报道的方法相比,本研究获得了相当或在某些情况下更好的结果。该方法在区分正常眼和不同阶段的圆锥角膜眼方面表现出非常好的准确性。在某些情况下,由于 KC 组的定义以及项目和参数选择的差异,无法直接将我们的结果与文献进行比较。