School of Computer Science, Carleton University, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Denver Health Hospital, Denver, Colorado, USA.
Ultrasound Med Biol. 2021 Oct;47(10):3002-3013. doi: 10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2021.06.011. Epub 2021 Aug 1.
As point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS) becomes more integrated into clinical practice, it is essential to address all aspects of ultrasound operator proficiency. Ultrasound proficiency requires the ability to acquire, interpret and integrate bedside ultrasound images. The difference in image acquisition psychomotor skills between novice (trainee) and expert (instructor) ultrasonographer has not been described. We created an inexpensive system, called Probe Watch, to record probe motion and assess image acquisition in cardiac POCUS using an inertial measurement device and software for data recording based on open-source components. We designed a temporal convolutional network for skills classification from probe motion that integrates clinical domain knowledge. We further designed data augmentation methods to improve its generalization. Subsequently, we validated the setup and assessment method on a set of novice and expert sonographers performing cardiac ultrasound in a simulation-based training environment. The proposed methods classified participants as novice or expert with areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 0.931 and 0.761 for snippets and trials, respectively. Integrating domain knowledge into the neural network had added value. Furthermore, we identified the most discriminative features for assessment. Probe Watch quantifies motion during cardiac ultrasound and provides insight into probe motion behavior. It may be deployed during cardiac ultrasound training to monitor learning curves objectively and automatically.
随着即时超声(POCUS)在临床实践中的应用越来越广泛,解决超声操作人员的所有方面的专业水平问题至关重要。超声技术的熟练程度需要具备获取、解释和整合床边超声图像的能力。然而,新手(受训者)和专家(教员)超声医师在图像获取运动技能方面的差异尚未得到描述。我们创建了一个名为 Probe Watch 的廉价系统,该系统使用惯性测量设备和基于开源组件的数据记录软件,记录探头运动并评估心脏即时超声中的图像获取情况。我们设计了一种基于时间卷积网络的技能分类方法,该方法将临床领域知识纳入其中。我们进一步设计了数据增强方法来提高其泛化能力。随后,我们在基于模拟培训环境的一组新手和专家超声医师进行心脏超声检查的情况下验证了该设置和评估方法。该方法对参与者进行分类,以接收者操作特征曲线下的面积为 0.931 和 0.761 的片段和试验,分别为新手或专家。将领域知识纳入神经网络具有附加价值。此外,我们确定了最具区分性的评估特征。Probe Watch 量化了心脏超声期间的探头运动,并深入了解探头运动行为。它可以在心脏超声培训期间部署,以客观且自动地监测学习曲线。