School of Management, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin, 150006, China.
School of Management, Ningxia University, Yinchuan, 750021, China.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2022 Jan;29(3):4375-4389. doi: 10.1007/s11356-021-15926-8. Epub 2021 Aug 18.
We use input-output analysis and Levinson's structural decomposition method to measure China's CO emissions under the no-trade hypothesis, to calculate how international trade affects China's emissions. We also analyze the driving factors of the difference between hypothetical no-trade CO emissions and actual emissions and discuss the existence of "Pollution Haven Hypothesis" (PHH) in China. The results show that (1) from 2000 to 2017, the hypothetical no-trade CO emissions are 2.43-14.67% lower than actual emissions. The scale effect is the main cause of this difference, while the composition effect fluctuates and has little impact. (2) Although exports make other economies' CO emissions transfer to China, imports also help avoid China's emissions from some carbon-intensive sectors. (3) International trade has little impact on the cleanliness of China's industry composition. The no-trade industry composition is slightly cleaner than the actual one before 2010, after which trade improves the cleanliness of industry composition to a small extent. PHH is invalid for China in recent years, and results for most developing countries do not support PHH. (4) The relationship between no-trade effects and income per capita for all the economies does not also support PHH. Most economies reduce emissions, and their industry compositions are cleaner because of trade, regardless of their development degree. Trade will not severely influence China's future emission reduction, and improving the cleanliness of carbon-intensive sectors should be paid more attention to.
我们使用投入产出分析和列文森的结构分解方法来衡量在无贸易假设下中国的二氧化碳排放,并计算国际贸易如何影响中国的排放。我们还分析了假设无贸易二氧化碳排放与实际排放之间差异的驱动因素,并讨论了中国是否存在“污染避难所假说”(PHH)。结果表明:(1)2000-2017 年,假设无贸易 CO 排放量比实际排放量低 2.43-14.67%。规模效应是造成这种差异的主要原因,而构成效应波动且影响较小。(2)尽管出口使其他经济体的 CO 排放转移到中国,但进口也有助于避免中国某些碳密集型行业的排放。(3)国际贸易对中国产业构成的清洁度影响不大。无贸易产业构成在 2010 年之前略优于实际情况,之后贸易在一定程度上提高了产业构成的清洁度。近年来 PHH 对中国无效,大多数发展中国家的结果也不支持 PHH。(4)所有经济体的无贸易效应与人均收入之间的关系也不支持 PHH。大多数经济体由于贸易减少了排放,其产业构成更加清洁,而不论其发展程度如何。贸易不会严重影响中国未来的减排,应更加关注提高碳密集型部门的清洁度。