Lim Youn Seon
Department of Science Education, Donald and Barbara Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/Northwell, 500 Hofstra University, Hempstead, NY 11549 USA.
Med Sci Educ. 2019 Jan 14;29(1):255-263. doi: 10.1007/s40670-018-00687-w. eCollection 2019 Mar.
In self-directed learning environments, students must monitor and assess their learning progress themselves. Formative assessments play a central role as instructional tools to train students in these self-assessment skills. Key to the effectiveness of a formative assessment as a training instrument is the degree of student involvement in the design and implementation of the formative assessment used to train them. Five characteristics are essential to secure a sufficient level of student involvement: (1) congruence (i.e., the tasks of a formative assessment must reflect the instructional content), (2) authenticity (i.e., the tasks of a formative assessment should be related to students' background and study context), (3) consultation (i.e., students should have a say in how their answers are evaluated based on which criteria), (4) transparency (i.e., no "mystery items"-the wording of the items must clearly addresses the targeted content), and (5) accommodation (i.e., all students should have the same chance to complete the items of a formative assessment). These five characteristics of student involvement were used . Different from extant approaches that typically rely on instructors' judgments to infer the degree of student involvement, this study uses a paradigm in higher educational research asking . Thus, here, students had to A total of 140 medical students participated in the study. Multivariate statistical methods were used to analyze the data. The majority of medical students appreciate the use of formative assessments to teach them self-directed learning skills; but the results also show that there is still room for increasing student involvement-especially, for minority students.
在自主学习环境中,学生必须自行监控和评估他们的学习进度。形成性评估作为教学工具,在培养学生这些自我评估技能方面发挥着核心作用。形成性评估作为一种培训工具的有效性的关键在于学生参与用于培训他们的形成性评估的设计和实施的程度。确保足够程度的学生参与有五个特征至关重要:(1)一致性(即形成性评估的任务必须反映教学内容),(2)真实性(即形成性评估的任务应与学生的背景和学习环境相关),(3)协商(即学生应该对根据哪些标准评估他们的答案有发言权),(4)透明度(即没有“神秘项目”——项目的措辞必须明确涉及目标内容),以及(5)适应性(即所有学生都应有相同的机会完成形成性评估的项目)。使用了学生参与的这五个特征。与通常依赖教师判断来推断学生参与程度的现有方法不同,本研究采用了高等教育研究中的一种范式进行询问。因此,在这里,学生必须……共有140名医学生参与了该研究。使用多元统计方法分析数据。大多数医学生赞赏使用形成性评估来教授他们自主学习技能;但结果也表明,增加学生参与度仍有空间——尤其是对少数族裔学生而言。