Atwa Hani Salem, Potu Bhagath Kumar, Fadel Raouf Abdelrahman, Deifalla Abdelhalim Salem, Fatima Ayesha, Othman Manal Ahmed, Sarwani Nasir Abdul Latif, Nasr El-Din Wael Amin
Medical Education Department, College of Medicine and Medical Sciences, Arabian Gulf University, Manama, Kingdom of Bahrain.
Medical Education Department, Faculty of Medicine, Suez Canal University, Ismailia, Egypt.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2024 Jun 10;15:551-563. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S465384. eCollection 2024.
Formative assessment with feedback is part of the assessment program in medical education to improve students' learning. Limited research has focused on its application and impact on practical anatomy education.
This study aimed to examine medical students' perceptions of formative assessment in practical anatomy sessions of body systems-based educational units and explore its influence on final practical exam performance. A descriptive, cross-sectional study was conducted. Data was collected from 173 Year 2 medical students through a survey that addressed their perception of process and importance of formative assessment and feedback. The survey employed a 5-point Likert scale. Two open-ended questions were appended at the end of the survey. Students' performance in Unit 3 (where formative assessment was conducted) was compared to their performance in Unit 2 (where no formative assessment was conducted) and with the performance of the previous academic year's students in Unit 3 (where no formative assessment was conducted). Descriptive statistics were used. The level of statistical significance was set at p-value < 0.05. Responses to open-ended questions (qualitative data) were counted, categorized as themes, and presented as frequencies and percentages.
The survey showed high internal consistency, and its validity was established through exploratory factor analysis. Results showed that the mean mark for the unit with formative assessment and feedback was significantly higher than for the units without formative assessment and feedback. Students showed positive perception of formative assessment and feedback conducted after practical anatomy sessions. They reported useful insights regarding the benefits they gained from formative assessment and feedback as well as constructive suggestions for future improvements.
The study indicates that students positively perceived formative assessment and feedback sessions after practical anatomy sessions. Findings also refer to a positive effect of formative assessment on students' performance in summative practical assessment in anatomy.
带有反馈的形成性评估是医学教育评估计划的一部分,旨在促进学生的学习。针对其在实践解剖学教育中的应用和影响的研究有限。
本研究旨在调查医学生对基于身体系统的教育单元实践解剖学课程中形成性评估的看法,并探讨其对最终实践考试成绩的影响。开展了一项描述性横断面研究。通过一项调查收集了173名二年级医学生的数据,该调查涉及他们对形成性评估和反馈的过程及重要性的看法。该调查采用5点李克特量表。在调查末尾附加了两个开放式问题。将学生在第3单元(进行了形成性评估)的表现与其在第2单元(未进行形成性评估)的表现以及上一学年学生在第3单元(未进行形成性评估)的表现进行比较。使用描述性统计方法。统计显著性水平设定为p值<0.05。对开放式问题的回答(定性数据)进行计数、归类为主题,并以频率和百分比形式呈现。
调查显示出较高的内部一致性,其有效性通过探索性因素分析得以确立。结果表明,有形成性评估和反馈的单元的平均成绩显著高于没有形成性评估和反馈的单元。学生对实践解剖学课程后进行的形成性评估和反馈持积极看法。他们报告了从形成性评估和反馈中获得的有益见解以及对未来改进的建设性建议。
该研究表明,学生对实践解剖学课程后的形成性评估和反馈持积极看法。研究结果还表明形成性评估对学生解剖学总结性实践评估的成绩有积极影响。