Abdulla Mohammed H, O'Sullivan Eleanor
Department of Physiology, School of Medicine, Western Gateway Building, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.
Department of Oral Surgery, Cork University Dental School and Hospital, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.
Med Sci Educ. 2019 Aug 1;29(4):959-968. doi: 10.1007/s40670-019-00780-8. eCollection 2019 Dec.
PowerPoint is widely used in higher education with reported advantages on student learning. The aim of this study was to examine the impact of detailed notes and videos as a supplement to PowerPoint slides on student attendance and performance. First-year medical students' opinion on whether the supplementary material assisted their learning of Physiology in addition to demographics was collected in a survey. Attendance was similar for participants who used notes and videos to those who did not, for male vs. female and for participants from biomedical vs. non-biomedical backgrounds. However, within the non-biomedical cohort, attendance of male respondents was significantly higher (95 ± 3 vs. 81 ± 6%, < 0.05), although both groups used notes and videos. Similarly, attendance of female participants of biomedical background was higher ( < 0.05) than female participants of non-biomedical background ( vs. : 94 ± 3 vs. 81 ± 6%) even though both cohorts used notes and videos. Providing notes and videos had no adverse impact on attendance (90 ± 2%, 8 lectures) and tended to enhance exam scores for low-performing students in the class when compared with those of previous years' cohorts ( vs. and : 61 ± 5% vs. 55 ± 6% and 47 ± 8%, respectively). There was an increase in the immediate gain of knowledge following watching/listening to videos ( vs. : 65 ± 3% vs. 48 ± 3%). The survey revealed a positive student perception of supplementary material mainly because they felt it reduced the time required to search for relevant information.
PowerPoint在高等教育中被广泛使用,据报道对学生学习有诸多益处。本研究旨在探讨详细笔记和视频作为PowerPoint幻灯片补充材料对学生出勤情况和学习成绩的影响。通过一项调查收集了一年级医学生对补充材料是否有助于他们学习生理学的看法以及人口统计学信息。使用笔记和视频的参与者与未使用的参与者、男性与女性参与者以及生物医学背景与非生物医学背景的参与者的出勤情况相似。然而,在非生物医学组中,尽管两组都使用了笔记和视频,但男性受访者的出勤率显著更高(95±3%对81±6%,P<0.05)。同样,生物医学背景的女性参与者的出勤率高于非生物医学背景的女性参与者(P<0.05)(分别为94±3%对81±6%),尽管两组都使用了笔记和视频。提供笔记和视频对出勤率没有负面影响(90±2%,8次讲座),并且与前几年的同龄人相比,对于班级中表现较差的学生,这往往会提高考试成绩(分别为61±5%对55±6%和47±8%)。观看/收听视频后,知识的即时获取有所增加(分别为65±3%对48±3%)。调查显示学生对补充材料有积极的看法,主要是因为他们觉得这减少了搜索相关信息所需的时间。