Vanderberg Rachel, Nikiforova Tanya, Hamm Megan, Spagnoletti Carla, McNeil Melissa
Division of General Internal Medicine, UPMC Montefiore Hospital, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, 200 Lothrop St., Pittsburgh, PA 15213 USA.
Qualitative, Evaluation and Stakeholder Engagement (Qual EASE) Research Core, University of Pittsburgh Center for Research on Health Care Data Center, Pittsburgh, PA USA.
Med Sci Educ. 2020 Oct 14;30(4):1445-1457. doi: 10.1007/s40670-020-01092-y. eCollection 2020 Dec.
Outpatient exam room presentations (OERPs) in resident continuity clinics could address several current challenges in graduate medical education including increasing patient satisfaction, enhancing patient-centered care, and operationalizing competency-based education through direct observation. The authors' aim of this study was to explore the positive and negative aspects of OERPs as a precepting model in resident continuity clinics and to develop a list of best practices for medical educators to utilize when conducting OERPs.
The authors defined an OERP as a case presentation and subsequent discussion taking place inside the exam room with the attending physician, resident physician, and patient present. Following a 1-month pilot period of conducting OERPs in internal medicine resident continuity clinics, the authors conducted individual phone interviews and focus groups with internal medicine attendings and residents, respectively. The authors analyzed transcripts using thematic analysis and the constant comparative method. Sixteen attendings participated in individual phone interviews and four resident focus groups averaged five participants per group.
Four main topics emerged: (1) effect of OERPs on patient care, (2) effect of OERPs on medical education, (3) barriers to OERPs, and (4) OERP best practices.
Participants noted both positive and negative effects of OERPs on patient care and medical education. Best practices suggested to maximize these benefits and minimize drawbacks included targeting OERPs to certain types of clinical encounters and employing strategies to preserve the resident physician-patient relationship and resident autonomy.
住院医师连续性诊所的门诊检查室汇报(OERP)可以应对研究生医学教育当前面临的若干挑战,包括提高患者满意度、加强以患者为中心的医疗,以及通过直接观察实施基于能力的教育。本研究作者的目的是探讨OERP作为住院医师连续性诊所带教模式的积极和消极方面,并制定一份医学教育工作者在进行OERP时可采用的最佳实践清单。
作者将OERP定义为在检查室内由主治医生、住院医生和患者共同参与的病例汇报及后续讨论。在内科住院医师连续性诊所进行了为期1个月的OERP试点后,作者分别对内科主治医生和住院医生进行了个人电话访谈和焦点小组访谈。作者采用主题分析和持续比较法对访谈记录进行了分析。16名主治医生参与了个人电话访谈,4个住院医生焦点小组每组平均有5名参与者。
出现了四个主要主题:(1)OERP对患者护理的影响,(2)OERP对医学教育的影响,(3)OERP的障碍,以及(4)OERP最佳实践。
参与者指出OERP对患者护理和医学教育既有积极影响也有消极影响。为了最大限度地发挥这些益处并尽量减少弊端而建议的最佳实践包括将OERP针对某些类型的临床会诊,并采用策略来维护住院医生与患者的关系以及住院医生的自主权。