Department of Biomedical Engineering, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-7575, USA.
Department of Computer Science, University of Central Arkansas, Conway, AR 72305, USA.
Mil Med. 2023 Mar 20;188(3-4):e637-e645. doi: 10.1093/milmed/usab361.
Assessment of functional recovery of service members following a concussion is central to their return to duty. Practical military-relevant performance-based tests are needed for identifying those who might need specialized rehabilitation, for evaluating the progress of recovery, and for making return-to-duty determinations. One such recently developed test is the 'Portable Warrior Test of Tactical Agility' (POWAR-TOTAL) assessment designed for use following concussion in an active duty population. This agility task involves maneuvers used in military training, such as rapid stand-to-prone and prone-to-stand transitions, combat rolls, and forward and backward running. The effect of concussion on the performance of such maneuvers has not been established.
The Institutional Review Board-approved study was conducted at Ft. Bragg, North Carolina, on 57 healthy control (HC) service members (SMs) and 42 well-matched SMs who were diagnosed with concussion and were referred for physical therapy with the intent to return to duty. Each study participant performed five consecutive trials of the POWAR-TOTAL task at full exertion while wearing inertial sensors, which were used to identify the constituent task maneuvers, or phases, and measure their durations. Statistical analyses were performed on durations of three main phases: (1) rising from prone and running, (2) lowering from vertical to prone, and (3) combat rolls.
None of the three phases showed significant correlation with age (range 18-45 years) in either group. Gradual improvement in all three phase durations across five trials was observed in the HC group, but not in the concussed group. On average, control subjects performed significantly faster (P < .004 or less) than concussed subjects in all trials in the lowering and rolling phases, but less so in the rising/running phase. Membership in the concussed group had a strong effect on the lowering phase (Cohen's d = 1.05), medium effect on the rolling phase (d = 0.72), and small effect on the rising/running phase (d = 0.49). Individuals in the HC group who had a history of prior concussions were intermediate between the concussed group and the never-concussed group in the lowering and rolling phases. Duration of transitional movements (lowering from standing to prone and combat rolls) was better at differentiating individuals' performance by group (receiver operating characteristic area under the curve [AUC] = 0.83) than the duration of the entire POWAR-TOTAL task (AUC = 0.71).
Inertial sensor analysis reveals that rapid transitional movements (such as lowering from vertical to prone position and combat rolls) are particularly discriminative between SMs recovering from concussion and their concussion-free peers. This analysis supports the validity of POWAR-TOTAL as a useful tool for therapists who serve military SMs.
评估士兵在脑震荡后的功能恢复情况对于他们重返工作岗位至关重要。为了确定那些可能需要专门康复治疗的患者,评估恢复进展情况并做出重返工作岗位的决定,需要实用的与军事相关的基于表现的测试。最近开发的一种此类测试是“便携式战士战术敏捷性测试”(POWAR-TOTAL)评估,用于在现役人员中脑震荡后使用。这项敏捷性任务涉及到在军事训练中使用的动作,例如快速站立到俯卧和俯卧到站立的转换、战斗翻滚、前后奔跑。脑震荡对这些动作表现的影响尚未确定。
这项经机构审查委员会批准的研究在北卡罗来纳州布拉格堡进行,共有 57 名健康对照组(HC)士兵(SM)和 42 名病情匹配的 SM 参加,他们被诊断患有脑震荡并被推荐接受物理治疗以恢复工作。每位研究参与者在穿着惯性传感器的情况下,全力进行五次连续的 POWAR-TOTAL 任务试验,惯性传感器用于识别组成任务的动作或阶段,并测量其持续时间。对三个主要阶段的持续时间进行了统计分析:(1)从俯卧位到站立位的起身和奔跑,(2)从垂直位到俯卧位的下降,(3)战斗翻滚。
在两组中,三个阶段的持续时间均与年龄(18-45 岁)无显著相关性。在 HC 组中,所有五个试验中的所有三个阶段的持续时间均逐渐改善,但在脑震荡组中没有观察到这种改善。平均而言,在所有试验中,对照组在下降和翻滚阶段的表现明显快于脑震荡组(P<0.004 或更小),但在起身/奔跑阶段的表现则较慢。脑震荡组的成员对下降阶段有很强的影响(Cohen's d=1.05),对翻滚阶段有中等影响(d=0.72),对起身/奔跑阶段有较小影响(d=0.49)。HC 组中曾有过脑震荡病史的个体在下降和翻滚阶段的表现介于脑震荡组和从未脑震荡组之间。过渡动作的持续时间(从站立到俯卧和战斗翻滚的下降)比整个 POWAR-TOTAL 任务的持续时间(AUC=0.71)更好地区分个体的表现(AUC=0.83)。
惯性传感器分析表明,快速过渡动作(例如从垂直位置下降到俯卧位置和战斗翻滚)在从脑震荡中恢复的士兵和他们无脑震荡的同伴之间具有特别强的区分能力。这种分析支持了 POWAR-TOTAL 作为治疗师为服务的军事士兵提供有用工具的有效性。