J Am Pharm Assoc (2003). 2021 Nov-Dec;61(6):678-693.e3. doi: 10.1016/j.japh.2021.08.014. Epub 2021 Aug 13.
Patients may contribute to various aspects of student pharmacists' education within clinical, experiential and educational settings. There is an emerging body of literature describing and evaluating the contribution of patients to health care education; however, little is known about patients' contribution to pharmacy education specifically within educational settings.
To explore the evidence relating to the involvement of patients in the education of student pharmacists, in terms of the nature, extent, and outcomes of their contribution.
A systematic literature search was undertaken within Embase, MEDLINE, Education Resources Information Center, International Pharmaceutical Abstracts, PubMed, PsycINFO, CINAHL, and Scopus databases from inception to April 10, 2020. Inclusion criteria included primary research studies reporting on the active involvement of patients in pharmacy education, within an educational setting. Quality assessment appraisal for the included studies was conducted using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool.
Twelve studies were eligible for inclusion in this systematic review. Nine studies explored the use of patients as educators providing valuable insight about their lived experience. Six studies involved patients in question-and-answer sessions, providing students with opportunities to inquire about their lived experience in relation to medicines, health care, and medical conditions. Studies that reported on students' learning outcomes demonstrated improvements in communication skills, deeper understanding of patients' lived experience particularly relating to mental illness, and increased confidence in providing care for patients. Among patients, participation in the educational process led to greater satisfaction, empowerment, and knowledge from sharing personal experiences. There were no clinical outcomes measured among patients participating in the included studies. The 5 nonrandomized quantitative studies ranged from low to moderate levels of quality, the 4 mixed-methods studies were of low quality, and the 3 qualitative studies were of high quality.
The involvement of patients in the education of student pharmacists was found to benefit both patients and students. Student-specific outcomes included development of communication skills and new insights about patients' lived experience. Further research is needed to better understand the long-term impact of patient involvement in pharmacy education, in terms of students' learning outcomes and clinical outcomes among patients.
患者可能会在临床、体验和教育环境中为学生药剂师的教育做出各种贡献。有大量文献描述和评估患者对医疗保健教育的贡献;然而,关于患者在教育环境中对药学教育的具体贡献,知之甚少。
探讨与患者参与学生药剂师教育相关的证据,包括他们贡献的性质、程度和结果。
对 Embase、MEDLINE、教育资源信息中心、国际药学文摘、PubMed、PsycINFO、CINAHL 和 Scopus 数据库进行了系统的文献检索,检索时间从建库到 2020 年 4 月 10 日。纳入标准包括报告患者在教育环境中积极参与药学教育的原始研究。使用混合方法评估工具对纳入研究进行质量评估。
本系统评价共纳入 12 项研究。9 项研究探讨了患者作为教育者的使用情况,为他们的生活经历提供了有价值的见解。6 项研究让患者参与问答环节,为学生提供了询问他们与药物、医疗保健和医疗状况相关的生活经历的机会。报告学生学习成果的研究表明,沟通技巧有所提高,对患者生活经历的理解加深,特别是对精神疾病的理解,以及对为患者提供护理的信心增强。患者参与教育过程后,满意度、赋权感和分享个人经验的知识有所提高。参与研究的患者没有测量临床结果。5 项非随机定量研究的质量从低到中等,4 项混合方法研究的质量较低,3 项定性研究的质量较高。
患者参与学生药剂师教育被发现对患者和学生都有益。学生的具体成果包括沟通技巧的发展和对患者生活经历的新见解。需要进一步研究以更好地了解患者参与药学教育对学生学习成果和患者临床结果的长期影响。