School of Social Work University of Maryland Baltimore County, Baltimore, Maryland, United States.
School of Social Work University of Maryland Baltimore, Baltimore, Maryland, United States.
Omega (Westport). 2023 Nov;88(1):139-156. doi: 10.1177/00302228211043694. Epub 2021 Sep 7.
This study examines the goals of medical aid-in-dying (MAID) legislation introduced to the US Congress from 1994-2020 using a policy mapping analysis approach. Using congress.gov, we identified 98 bills, 23 bills were analyzed in this study. Most of the bills aimed to restrict the use of federal funds, to regulate the drugs commonly used for MAID, to prohibit the development of policies or practices supporting MAID, and to regulate practitioners' roles in MAID. In practice, these bills would limit patient access to MAID by restricting drugs, funds, health care services, legal assistance, policy, and research. These findings suggest there lacks congressional support for MAID, even though polls of the public are divided yet favorable. Policymakers who support MAID should consider affirmative policies that 1) prevent MAID policies from discriminating against vulnerable groups, 2) support funding to study the use of MAID, and 3) build avenues to allow all qualified people to access MAID in places where it is legal.
本研究使用政策图谱分析方法,考察了 1994 年至 2020 年期间引入美国国会的医疗辅助死亡(MAID)立法的目标。利用 congress.gov,我们确定了 98 项法案,其中 23 项法案在本研究中进行了分析。大多数法案旨在限制联邦资金的使用,规范常用于 MAID 的药物,禁止制定支持 MAID 的政策或做法,并规范从业者在 MAID 中的角色。实际上,这些法案会通过限制药物、资金、医疗保健服务、法律援助、政策和研究来限制患者获得 MAID 的机会。这些发现表明,即使公众的民意调查存在分歧但仍倾向于支持,国会对 MAID 的支持仍然不足。支持 MAID 的政策制定者应考虑采取积极政策,即 1)防止 MAID 政策歧视弱势群体,2)支持研究 MAID 使用的资金,以及 3)建立渠道,允许所有符合条件的人在合法的地方获得 MAID。