Sligo Mental Health Services, Clarion Rd, Sligo, Ireland.
Research and Academic Institute of Athens, Athens, Greece.
Aging Clin Exp Res. 2022 Mar;34(3):633-642. doi: 10.1007/s40520-021-01978-w. Epub 2021 Sep 9.
Delirium is associated with a variety of adverse healthcare outcomes but is highly predictable, preventable and treatable. For this reason, numerous guidelines have been developed for delirium recognition, prevention and management across different countries and disciplines. Although research is adduced as evidence for these guidelines, a constant finding is the lack of implementation if they exist at all. Implementation is a human behaviour that can be influenced by various factors including culture at a micro- and macro-level. Hofstede's model proposes that national cultures vary along six consistent dimensions.
Using this model, we examined the nature of delirium guidelines across countries in relation to Hofstede's six cultural dimensions.
Data collected for each country on: the six dimensions of Hofstede's model, number of delirium guidelines approved by a National professional body of each country (through searching databases), the annual old-age dependency ratio for each country.
Sixty-four countries had the completed six dimensions of Hofstede's model. Twenty of them (31%) had one or more delirium guidelines. The total number of different delirium guidelines was 45. Countries with formal delirium guidelines have significantly lower power distance among their members, are more individualistic societies, have lower levels of uncertainty avoidance and higher old-age dependency ratio compared to those without delirium guidelines.
DISCUSSION/CONCLUSION: The development and implementation of delirium guidelines vary across countries. Specific combinations of cultural dimensions influence the production of delirium guidelines. Understanding these important cultural differences can facilitate more widespread acceptance and implementation of guidelines.
谵妄与多种不良医疗结果相关,但具有高度可预测性、可预防性和可治疗性。因此,许多国家和学科都制定了谵妄识别、预防和管理的指南。尽管研究为这些指南提供了证据,但如果存在的话,实施情况却始终不尽如人意。实施是一种人类行为,可以受到各种因素的影响,包括微观和宏观层面的文化。霍夫斯泰德的模型提出,国家文化在六个一致的维度上存在差异。
使用该模型,我们考察了各国谵妄指南与霍夫斯泰德的六个文化维度之间的关系。
为每个国家收集的数据包括:霍夫斯泰德模型的六个维度、每个国家国家专业机构批准的谵妄指南数量(通过搜索数据库)、每个国家的年度老年人口依存度。
64 个国家完成了霍夫斯泰德模型的六个维度。其中 20 个(31%)国家有一个或多个谵妄指南。不同的谵妄指南总数为 45 个。有正式谵妄指南的国家,其成员之间的权力距离明显较低,是更具个体主义的社会,不确定性规避程度较低,老年人口依存度较高,而没有谵妄指南的国家则相反。
讨论/结论:谵妄指南的制定和实施在各国之间存在差异。文化维度的特定组合影响谵妄指南的制定。了解这些重要的文化差异可以促进更广泛地接受和实施指南。