De Vita Francesca, Schmidt Susanna, Tinti Carla, Re Anna Maria
Department of Psychology, University of Turin, Turin, Italy.
Front Psychol. 2021 Aug 27;12:738395. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.738395. eCollection 2021.
Literature has extensively demonstrated the coordination role of working memory (WM) in complex tasks such as writing. However, previous studies mostly concentrated on the relation between passive WM (e.g., WM span) components and specific writing tasks (e.g., dictation). Here, we aimed to investigate the relationship between different writing skills and the performance on a WM updating task measuring the more active components of WM. From a pool of 160 Italian pupils (grades 3-5), we selected 46 children divided in two groups based on their WM updating performance. The first group consisted of 21 children with low WM updating performance (≤10th percentile), the second group consisted of 25 children with high WM updating performance (≥90th percentile). All children were tested on a battery of writing tasks to assess writing speed, orthographic skills, and competences in expressive writing. MANOVAs and a discriminant analysis were computed to assess group differences and the contribution of the different writing tests in correctly predicting group membership. The results revealed that children with high WM updating performance scored significantly higher than children with low WM updating performance on most of the writing tasks. These results highlight the relevant role of the active components of WM on writing processes. In addition, they suggest that the improvement of writing skills should rely not only on the training of the specific processes implied in this complex task, but also on the training of the cognitive processes that support them, such as active WM processes.
文献已广泛证明工作记忆(WM)在诸如写作等复杂任务中的协调作用。然而,先前的研究大多集中在被动工作记忆(如工作记忆广度)成分与特定写作任务(如听写)之间的关系上。在此,我们旨在研究不同写作技能与一项测量工作记忆更活跃成分的工作记忆更新任务表现之间的关系。从160名意大利小学生(三年级至五年级)中,我们根据他们的工作记忆更新表现挑选出46名儿童,分为两组。第一组由21名工作记忆更新表现较低(≤第10百分位数)的儿童组成,第二组由25名工作记忆更新表现较高(≥第90百分位数)的儿童组成。所有儿童都接受了一系列写作任务测试,以评估写作速度、正字法技能和表达性写作能力。计算多变量方差分析和判别分析,以评估组间差异以及不同写作测试在正确预测组成员身份方面的贡献。结果显示,在大多数写作任务中,工作记忆更新表现较高的儿童得分显著高于工作记忆更新表现较低的儿童。这些结果突出了工作记忆的活跃成分在写作过程中的相关作用。此外,它们表明写作技能的提高不仅应依赖于对这项复杂任务中所涉及的特定过程的训练,还应依赖于对支持这些过程的认知过程的训练,如活跃的工作记忆过程。