Silfee Valerie, Williams Kelly, Leber Brett, Kogan Jane, Nikolajski Cara, Szigethy Eva, Serio Catherine
UPMC Health Plan, Pittsburgh, PA, United States.
UPMC Center for High-Value Health Care, Pittsburgh, PA, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2021 Sep 28;5(9):e28538. doi: 10.2196/28538.
Despite the growing evidence indicating the efficacy of digital cognitive behavioral interventions (dCBIs) for behavioral health (BH) treatment, broad and consistent use of such interventions has been limited by knowledge obtained in real-world settings, including factors that impact provider uptake/referral. Engaging providers early in the implementation process offers an opportunity to explore their needs and behaviors, integrate interventions into workflows, and better understand provider setting capabilities.
This study assessed providers' views on the feasibility and acceptability of delivering a cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)-based mobile app in multiple care settings.
Participating providers included BH and physical health (PH) providers from a women's health center, an outpatient BH clinic, and both rural/urban primary care settings. All participating providers cocreated workflows through facilitated workshops, including establishing feedback loops between the project team and providers and identifying clinical champions at each site. Over a 12-week period, the providers referred adult patients experiencing anxiety or depression to a mobile app-based dCBI, RxWell, and provided other indicated treatments as part of usual care. Referrals were completed by the providers through the electronic medical record. To better understand facilitators of and challenges in integrating RxWell into routine practice and perceptions of sustainability, a series of qualitative interviews was conducted. Interview data were analyzed to identify major themes using an inductive content analysis approach.
A total of 19 provider interviews were conducted to discover motivators and barriers for referring RxWell. The providers benefited from a focused discussion on how to incorporate the referral process into their workflow, and knowing the app content was rooted in evidence. Although the providers believed engaging in experiential learning was important, they indicated that more education on the digital health coach role and how to monitor patient progress is needed. The providers thought patient engagement may be impacted by motivation, a lack of comfort using a smartphone, or preference for in-person therapy. The providers also expressed enthusiasm in continuing to refer the app. They liked the ability to provide patients with support between sessions, to have an extra treatment option that teaches BH exercises, and to have a CBT treatment option that overcomes barriers (eg, wait times, copays, travel) to traditional therapy modalities.
Digital intervention success in health care settings relies heavily on engagement of key stakeholders, such as providers, in both design and implementation of the intervention and focused evaluation within intended care setting(s). Scaling digital interventions to meet the mental health needs of patients in usual care settings leans on thoughtfully constructed and streamlined workflows to enable seamless referral of patients by providers. Our findings strongly suggest that providers are supportive of digital tool integration to support the mental health of patients and endorse its use within their routine workflow.
尽管越来越多的证据表明数字认知行为干预(dCBIs)对行为健康(BH)治疗有效,但这种干预措施在现实环境中的广泛和持续应用受到了一些因素的限制,这些因素包括影响提供者采用/转诊的因素等。在实施过程的早期让提供者参与,为探索他们的需求和行为、将干预措施整合到工作流程中以及更好地了解提供者所在机构的能力提供了机会。
本研究评估了提供者对在多种护理环境中提供基于认知行为疗法(CBT)的移动应用程序的可行性和可接受性的看法。
参与的提供者包括来自妇女健康中心、门诊行为健康诊所以及农村/城市初级保健机构的行为健康和身体健康(PH)提供者。所有参与的提供者通过促进式研讨会共同创建工作流程,包括在项目团队和提供者之间建立反馈回路,并在每个地点确定临床倡导者。在12周的时间里,提供者将患有焦虑或抑郁的成年患者转诊至基于移动应用程序的dCBI(RxWell),并提供其他指定的常规护理治疗。转诊由提供者通过电子病历完成。为了更好地理解将RxWell整合到常规实践中的促进因素和挑战以及对可持续性的看法,进行了一系列定性访谈。使用归纳性内容分析方法对访谈数据进行分析以确定主要主题。
共进行了19次提供者访谈,以发现转诊RxWell的动机和障碍。提供者从关于如何将转诊过程纳入其工作流程的重点讨论中受益,并且了解到该应用程序的内容有证据支持。尽管提供者认为参与体验式学习很重要,但他们表示需要更多关于数字健康教练角色以及如何监测患者进展的教育。提供者认为患者参与可能会受到动机、使用智能手机不自在或更喜欢面对面治疗的影响。提供者还对继续转诊该应用程序表示出热情。他们喜欢能够在疗程之间为患者提供支持、拥有一种额外的教授行为健康练习的治疗选择以及拥有一种克服传统治疗方式障碍(如等待时间、自付费用、行程)的认知行为疗法治疗选择。
医疗保健环境中数字干预的成功在很大程度上依赖于关键利益相关者(如提供者)在干预的设计和实施以及在预期护理环境中的重点评估中的参与。扩大数字干预以满足常规护理环境中患者的心理健康需求依赖于精心构建和简化的工作流程,以使提供者能够无缝转诊患者。我们的研究结果强烈表明,提供者支持整合数字工具以支持患者的心理健康,并认可在其常规工作流程中使用该工具。