Joss E, Carrel R, Vuille J C
Institut für Sozial- und Präventivmedizin der Universität Bern.
Helv Paediatr Acta. 1987 Jun;42(5-6):371-85.
A prospective study to evaluate well-child examinations was based on a sample of 750 children drawn at random from the patients of 15 practising paediatricians who participated in the study. These children were followed from the age of 3 months, when each who was vaccinated also received a specified examination, until the age of 5 years. Participation in the program of examinations was still 86% at the age of 18 months. By the age of 4 1/2, the participation rate had dropped to 40%. Between the ages of 3 months and 18 months, 11.2% of the sample had been diagnosed as having a pathological disorder. Of the 97 diagnoses, 35 were detected during the newborn period; 25 were detected by means other than the well-child examinations; and 37 were directly attributable to the examinations. 28 of the 97 diagnoses were still valid at the age of 5 years, and 5 of those children had a serious handicap. In an additional 59 suspected diagnoses (7.8%) only 6 could later be confirmed as a pathological condition. Of the 300 children who attended the last well-child examination at age 4 1/2, 45 (15%) had one or more pathological findings. Seventeen of the 45 diagnoses were detected between the 18-month exam and the 4 1/2-year exam, and 30 were detected at the time of the last examination. The number of diagnoses per physician varied. From each sample of 50 children per doctor, 1 to 20 children would have a disorder. Twelve of the 15 paediatricians were appreciative of the structured exam schedule, and most intended to continue with some parts of the program after the study's termination.
一项评估健康儿童检查的前瞻性研究,基于从参与该研究的15名执业儿科医生的患者中随机抽取的750名儿童样本。这些儿童从3个月大开始跟踪,当时每个接种疫苗的儿童也接受了特定检查,直到5岁。在18个月大时,参与检查项目的比例仍为86%。到4岁半时,参与率降至40%。在3个月至18个月之间,样本中有11.2%被诊断患有病理疾病。在97例诊断中,35例在新生儿期被检测到;25例通过健康儿童检查以外的其他方式被检测到;37例直接归因于检查。97例诊断中有28例在5岁时仍然有效,其中5名儿童有严重残疾。在另外59例疑似诊断(7.8%)中,只有6例后来被确认为病理状况。在4岁半参加最后一次健康儿童检查的300名儿童中,45名(15%)有一个或多个病理发现。45例诊断中有17例在18个月检查至4岁半检查之间被检测到,30例在最后一次检查时被检测到。每位医生的诊断数量各不相同。从每位医生的每组50名儿童样本中,有1至20名儿童会患有疾病。15名儿科医生中有12名对结构化检查时间表表示赞赏,大多数人打算在研究结束后继续该项目的某些部分。