Quadrant Health Economics Inc, Cambridge, Ontario, Canada.
Seqirus USA Inc., Summit, NJ, USA.
Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2021 Nov 2;17(11):4603-4610. doi: 10.1080/21645515.2021.1971017. Epub 2021 Sep 22.
In the United Kingdom (UK), both the MF59-adjuvanted quadrivalent influenza vaccine (aQIV) and the high-dose QIV (QIV-HD) are preferred for persons aged 65 years and older but only aQIV is reimbursed by the National Health Service (NHS). The objective was to determine the potential cost-effectiveness of vaccinating adults aged 65 years and above with aQIV compared with QIV-HD in the UK. A dynamic transmission model, calibrated to match infection data from the UK, was used to estimate the impact of vaccination in 10 influenza seasons. Vaccine effectiveness was based on a meta-analysis that concluded the vaccines were not significantly different. Vaccine coverage, physician visits, hospitalizations, deaths, utility losses and NHS costs were estimated using published UK sources. The list price of aQIV was £11.88 while a range of prices were tested for QIV-HD. The price of the trivalent high-dose vaccine (TIV-HD) is £20.00 but a list price for QIV-HD is not yet available. The projected differences between the vaccines in terms of clinical cases and influenza treatment costs are minimal. Our analysis demonstrates that in order to be cost-effective, the price of QIV-HD must be similar to that of aQIV and may range from £7.57 to £12.94 depending on the relative effectiveness of the vaccines. The results of the analysis were most sensitive to variation in vaccine effectiveness and the rate of hospitalization due to influenza. Given the evidence, aQIV is cost-saving unless QIV-HD is priced lower than the existing list price of TIV-HD.
在英国(UK),MF59 佐剂四价流感疫苗(aQIV)和高剂量四价流感疫苗(QIV-HD)均被推荐用于 65 岁及以上人群,但只有 aQIV 可由国民保健制度(NHS)报销。本研究旨在确定在英国为 65 岁及以上成年人接种 aQIV 而非 QIV-HD 的潜在成本效益。采用动态传播模型,根据英国的感染数据进行校准,以估计 10 个流感季节疫苗接种的影响。疫苗效力基于一项荟萃分析,该分析得出的结论是,两种疫苗没有显著差异。使用已发表的英国资料估算疫苗接种覆盖率、医生就诊、住院、死亡、效用损失和 NHS 成本。aQIV 的定价为 11.88 英镑,而 QIV-HD 的价格则测试了一系列价格。三价高剂量疫苗(TIV-HD)的定价为 20.00 英镑,但尚未确定 QIV-HD 的定价。疫苗在临床病例和流感治疗成本方面的预期差异极小。我们的分析表明,为了具有成本效益,QIV-HD 的价格必须与 aQIV 相似,并且可能在 7.57 英镑至 12.94 英镑之间,具体取决于疫苗的相对效力。分析结果对疫苗效力和因流感导致的住院率的变化最为敏感。鉴于现有证据,如果 QIV-HD 的价格低于现有的 TIV-HD 定价,则 aQIV 具有成本效益。