Shaban Sami, Tariq Irfan, Elzubeir Margaret, Alsuwaidi Ahmed R, Basheer Alsajir, Magzoub Mohi
Department of Medical Education, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, United Arab Emirates University, PO Box 17666, Al Ain, UAE.
Department of Pediatrics, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, United Arab Emirates University, Al Ain, UAE.
BMC Med Educ. 2021 Sep 26;21(1):508. doi: 10.1186/s12909-021-02945-9.
Objective Structured Clinical Examinations (OSCEs) are an essential part of the assessment process for medical students. They have traditionally been face-to-face assessments, however, due to the COVID-19 pandemic, medical schools have been forced to attempt to carry them out remotely. OSCEs are difficult to carry out online due to rotation management aspects which make it difficult to synchronize movement of students from one station to another.
The authors have developed a dynamic OSCE time management website which aids in solving the movement synchronization issue. This secure website enables participants to view the list of stations they are allowed to enter, and the start and end time of each station. OSCE administrators can control time of entry and monitor progress of the OSCE remotely.
The authors have used the system to conduct several exams successfully, showing the feasibility and cost effectiveness of this method, as well as user acceptance and satisfaction. In contrast to traditional OSCEs, students are set up in individual virtual rooms for the whole exam while examiners, simulated patients and proctors rotate between them.
This online OSCE implementation shows feasibility, cost effectiveness and acceptance of this method. The authors found that student outcomes are comparable to traditional OSCEs conducted in the past. There was no significant difference in student marks in one exam compared to last year, while marks were slightly higher in two exams, potentially due to lack of physical exam stations. An unresolved drawback is the inability to assess physical exam stations online, although having students verbally describe what they would do in physical exam situations may be a partial solution.
客观结构化临床考试(OSCEs)是医学生评估过程的重要组成部分。传统上,它们是面对面的评估,但由于新冠疫情,医学院校被迫尝试远程进行这些考试。由于轮转管理方面的问题,OSCEs很难在线进行,这使得学生从一个站点到另一个站点的移动同步变得困难。
作者开发了一个动态OSCE时间管理网站,有助于解决移动同步问题。这个安全的网站使参与者能够查看他们被允许进入的站点列表以及每个站点的开始和结束时间。OSCE管理员可以远程控制进入时间并监控OSCE的进展情况。
作者使用该系统成功进行了几次考试,证明了这种方法的可行性和成本效益,以及用户的接受度和满意度。与传统的OSCEs不同,在整个考试过程中,学生被安排在单独的虚拟房间里,而考官、模拟患者和监考人员在他们之间轮流。
这种在线OSCE的实施显示了这种方法的可行性、成本效益和可接受性。作者发现学生的成绩与过去进行的传统OSCEs相当。与去年相比,一次考试中学生的成绩没有显著差异,而在两次考试中成绩略高,这可能是由于没有实际操作考试站点。一个尚未解决的缺点是无法在线评估实际操作考试站点,尽管让学生口头描述他们在实际操作考试情况下会做什么可能是一个部分解决方案。