Bartling Mona, Robinson Anthony C, Resch Bernd, Eitzinger Anton, Atzmanstorfer Karl
Department of Geoinformatics - Z_GIS, University of Salzburg, Austria.
Department of Geography, GeoVISTA Center, the Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, USA.
Cartogr Geogr Inf Sci. 2021 Jul 6;48(5):432-448. doi: 10.1080/15230406.2021.1933595. eCollection 2021.
Mobile map applications are typically used by a broad range of users. Users can be diverse in their context attributes (e.g. map use experience, activities during map use), and several previous user experience (UX) studies have focused on understanding how some contextual factors influence the UX for designing maps that satisfy users' needs. A need for research remains to evaluate the relationship between user context, UX, and variants of mobile map element design. In this article, we present our research investigating the interplay of these factors through an empirical user study with citizens in Austria. We created an online survey and generated 84 map variations, combining seven map-related tasks, three base map styles, two map detail densities, and two time-pressure variants. We tested these map variations with 107 survey participants and related their UX to user context. Map-related tasks emerged as a dominant factor modifying the map design UX. Further results showed that interactivity loaded map-related tasks were aided when paired with low detail-dense base maps, contrasting overlay features. We recommend future research to analyze an extended set of context attributes with additional participant data, to evaluate dynamic variations in context, and to find ways to dynamically monitor mobile map design UX.
移动地图应用通常被广泛的用户使用。用户在其上下文属性方面可能各不相同(例如地图使用经验、地图使用期间的活动),并且之前的一些用户体验(UX)研究专注于理解某些上下文因素如何影响UX,以便设计出满足用户需求的地图。仍有必要进行研究来评估用户上下文、用户体验和移动地图元素设计变体之间的关系。在本文中,我们通过对奥地利公民进行实证用户研究,展示了我们对这些因素之间相互作用的研究。我们创建了一项在线调查,并生成了84种地图变体,结合了七个与地图相关的任务、三种基础地图样式、两种地图细节密度和两种时间压力变体。我们用107名调查参与者测试了这些地图变体,并将他们的用户体验与用户上下文相关联。与地图相关的任务成为改变地图设计用户体验的主导因素。进一步的结果表明,当与低细节密度的基础地图配对时,交互式加载的与地图相关的任务会得到帮助,突出叠加特征。我们建议未来的研究分析一组扩展的上下文属性以及额外的参与者数据,以评估上下文中的动态变化,并找到动态监测移动地图设计用户体验的方法。