Kaufman Michelle R, Levine Deb, Casella Albert, DuBois David L
Department of Health, Behavior & Society, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, 624 N. Broadway, Room 257, Baltimore, MD 21204 USA.
DKF Productions, Oakland, CA USA.
Adolesc Res Rev. 2022;7(1):63-78. doi: 10.1007/s40894-021-00172-3. Epub 2021 Sep 18.
Electronic mentoring (e-mentoring), the integration of digital technology in mentoring relationships, has recently grown in popularity; however, the effectiveness of e-mentoring in addressing youth health has not been synthesized to date. The current study synthesizes the literature on e-mentoring to affect the health and well-being of youth (10-24 years) through a systematic review and evidence quality assessment. A total of 833 records were identified, of which 14 met eligibility criteria (published in English since 1995, targeted youth health and/or youth with health issues, and communication was entirely digital or combined with in-person interaction). The results showed that the majority of health-focused e-mentoring studies were conducted with young people with existing health conditions rather than on the use of e-mentoring to promote overall health and wellness. The included programs focused largely on bringing mentoring to youth subpopulations that may be challenged by in-person models. Quality assessments of the included studies showed that the strength of the evidence is mediocre. The findings suggest that e-mentoring has the potential to reach youth with unique health concerns and to promote independent management of health conditions as youth transition to adulthood; however, more rigorous evaluation of e-mentoring programs with larger sample sizes is needed.
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s40894-021-00172-3.
电子指导(e指导),即将数字技术融入指导关系,近来越来越受欢迎;然而,e指导在解决青少年健康问题方面的有效性至今尚未得到综合分析。本研究通过系统综述和证据质量评估,综合了关于e指导对青少年(10至24岁)健康和幸福影响的文献。共识别出833条记录,其中14条符合纳入标准(自1995年以来以英文发表,针对青少年健康和/或有健康问题的青少年,且交流完全是数字化的或与面对面互动相结合)。结果表明,大多数以健康为重点的e指导研究是针对已有健康状况的年轻人开展的,而非关于使用e指导来促进整体健康和幸福。纳入的项目主要侧重于为那些可能受到面对面模式挑战的青少年亚群体提供指导。对纳入研究的质量评估表明,证据力度一般。研究结果表明,e指导有潜力接触到有独特健康问题的青少年,并在青少年向成年过渡时促进其对健康状况的自主管理;然而,需要对样本量更大的e指导项目进行更严格的评估。
在线版本包含可在10.1007/s40894-021-00172-3获取的补充材料。