Kaufman Michelle R, Wright Kate, Eschliman Evan L, Levine Deborah, Simon Jeannette
Department of Health, Behavior and Society, Bloomberg School of Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, United States.
Ananizach, Baltimore, MD, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2023 Oct 27;7:e48515. doi: 10.2196/48515.
Mentoring can promote positive youth development. Owing to social and structural factors, young people in underresourced communities often lack adequate access to mentors, and naturally occurring mentors are more common than formal, programmatic mentors. There is little information on the impact of naturally occurring mentors on youth in general and even less on the role that mentors may play in promoting healthy outcomes in sexual and gender minority youth. African American young men who have sex with men (YMSM) are more likely to reside in communities with limited access to formalized mentorship programs and may benefit from naturally occurring mentoring relationships that address health outcomes, specifically related to HIV.
This study is a usability test of a mobile app designed for the mentors of African American YMSM to increase mentors' knowledge of and confidence in talking about HIV prevention and related topics with mentees.
Following consent, eligible and naturally occurring mentoring pairs involving African American YMSM in Baltimore; Philadelphia; and Washington, District of Columbia, tested the app, UrbanMentorHub, for usability. Participants downloaded the app and used it for 1 month, completed pre- and postintervention surveys, and participated in a follow-up focus group discussion. Participants' sociodemographic characteristics and HIV- and mentorship-related measures were characterized using descriptive statistics. Wilcoxon signed rank tests were used to test for pre- and postintervention differences in knowledge, confidence, and outcome expectancy measures. Focus group discussions were audio recorded and transcribed. Transcripts were thematically coded and analyzed to identify ways that UrbanMentorHub could be improved in the mentoring context.
Nine mentorship pairs participated in this usability study (N=18). Mentors obtained high scores on knowledge, confidence, outcome expectancies, skills, and intentions related to HIV and mentoring. No pre- or postintervention changes were observed in these measures. Mentors reported usually initiating conversations around HIV testing and pre-exposure prophylaxis; mentees and mentors equally initiated conversations on sexual practices and same-sex relationships. Mentors reported sexual practices as the most frequently discussed topic in the past month and pre-exposure prophylaxis being the least discussed. Mentees reported high comfort with HIV-related conversations. No pre- or postintervention change was observed regarding HIV knowledge. Most mentees reported having discussed most HIV-related topics with their mentor in the past month. Mentor feedback on the app was mostly neutral, although they reported positive perceptions of the idea of the app, indicating the potential for addressing a need in their communities. Mentors suggested ways to improve the app content and design elements.
Although there was no observed statistical change in measured outcomes, and qualitative feedback was overall neutral, the results of this usability study can inform future work to design and promote interventions and resources that support mentoring relationships for African American YMSM.
指导可以促进青少年的积极发展。由于社会和结构因素,资源匮乏社区的年轻人往往难以获得足够的指导机会,自然形成的指导者比正式的、有组织的指导者更为常见。关于自然形成的指导者对青少年的总体影响的信息很少,而关于指导者在促进性少数和性别少数青少年健康成果方面可能发挥的作用的信息更少。与男性发生性关系的非裔美国青年(YMSM)更有可能居住在难以获得正规指导计划的社区,可能会从解决健康问题,特别是与艾滋病毒相关问题的自然形成的指导关系中受益。
本研究是对一款为非裔美国YMSM的指导者设计的移动应用程序的可用性测试,以提高指导者在与被指导者谈论艾滋病毒预防及相关话题方面的知识和信心。
在获得同意后,来自巴尔的摩、费城和哥伦比亚特区华盛顿的符合条件的自然形成的涉及非裔美国YMSM的指导配对测试了该应用程序UrbanMentorHub的可用性。参与者下载该应用程序并使用1个月,完成干预前后的调查,并参加后续的焦点小组讨论。使用描述性统计来描述参与者的社会人口特征以及与艾滋病毒和指导相关的指标。使用Wilcoxon符号秩检验来测试干预前后在知识、信心和结果预期指标方面的差异。焦点小组讨论进行了录音和转录。对转录本进行主题编码和分析,以确定在指导背景下可以改进UrbanMentorHub的方法。
九对指导配对参与了这项可用性研究(N = 18)。指导者在与艾滋病毒和指导相关的知识、信心、结果预期、技能和意图方面获得了高分。在这些指标上未观察到干预前后的变化。指导者报告通常围绕艾滋病毒检测和暴露前预防展开对话;被指导者和指导者同样会就性行为和同性关系展开对话。指导者报告性行为是过去一个月中讨论最频繁的话题,而暴露前预防是讨论最少的数据。被指导者报告对与艾滋病毒相关的对话高度自在。在艾滋病毒知识方面未观察到干预前后的变化。大多数被指导者报告在过去一个月中与他们的指导者讨论了大多数与艾滋病毒相关的话题。指导者对该应用程序的反馈大多是中性的,尽管他们对该应用程序的理念有积极的看法,表明该应用程序有潜力满足他们社区的需求。指导者提出了改进应用程序内容和设计元素的方法。
尽管在测量结果中未观察到统计学上的变化,且定性反馈总体为中性,但这项可用性研究的结果可为未来设计和推广支持非裔美国YMSM指导关系的干预措施和资源的工作提供参考。